Experts sound alarm as reports of botched surgeries and misidentified body parts arise: ‘Inconsistent, inaccurate, and unreliable’
More and more industries are investing in and relying on AI, including surgeons in the operating room. But according to a study ReutersRegulators are experiencing an increase in safety reports and lawsuits when algorithms manipulate surgical instruments.
What’s going on?
U.S. regulators have received more than 1,401 reports of devices on the FDA’s AI list since 2021, according to court filings and Food and Drug Administration records. Allegations include botched surgeries and software misidentifying body parts.
For example, the sinus surgery device called TruDi Navigation System was updated to include artificial intelligence in 2021. According to FDA adverse event reports cited by Reuters, there were seven malfunction reports before AI was added and at least 100 malfunction and adverse event reports after the update. Two patients in Texas allegedly suffered strokes after their surgeons were misinformed about the location of surgical instruments near the carotid artery.
“[Acclarent] The lawsuit alleges that the alleged AI knew or should have known that the integrated navigation system product caused or increased its tendency to be inconsistent, inaccurate and unreliable, Reuters reported.
Integra LifeSciences commented to Reuters, saying there was “no credible evidence” linking AI technology to injuries.
Why is artificial intelligence in surgery a concern?
Washington University medical school instructor Dr. According to Alexander Everhart, AI-supported medical devices may pose safety risks, especially since they do not need to undergo clinical trials in patients. This includes a prenatal ultrasound tool called Sonio Detect, which allegedly misidentifies fetal body parts, and heart monitors manufactured by Medtronic, which allegedly fail to recognize abnormal rhythms.
According to Everhart, the FDA’s “traditional” methods of regulating devices are not effective in ensuring that AI-powered technology is safe, especially for medical treatments. For example, an investigative letter published in JAMA Health Forum and cited by Reuters found that AI medical devices were linked to 182 recalls, with 43% of those recalls occurring less than a year after authorization.
Along with reported medical risks, the use of AI is straining energy systems worldwide. AI systems may require significant amounts of electricity and water resources while increasing energy demands and costs. At the same time, AI with smart grid optimization can help increase clean energy integration and efficiency, showing that such technologies can be both promising and risky.
What is being done about artificial intelligence medical devices?
A spokesperson for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, quoted by Reuters, said patient safety remains a top priority and the agency will continue to learn more about artificial intelligence and digital health. The FDA has expanded its staff of AI experts, but former employees said staff cuts have increased the workload.
As AI becomes more integrated into everyday products and various industries, it becomes important for consumers to understand how these emerging technologies are marketed. Educating yourself about it greenwash It can help evaluate corporate promises.
Get TCDs free newsletters For easy tips to save more, waste less, and make smarter choices — and win up to $5,000 in neat TCD-exclusive upgrades Reward Club.
