Dr Robby’s fate is revealed. But did fans ruin it for themselves?
Updated ,first published
This story contains spoilers for the season two finale. Pitt.
Dr Robby (Noah Wyle) is not dead. He hasn’t crashed his motorcycle, the ghost of which has been purring in the background all season long. Dr. As Abbot (Shawn Hatosy) warned, he “didn’t pull Thelma and Louise” and jumped off the cliff where they used to lead the buffalos to their deaths. In fact, he didn’t even leave the hospital.
We see him embracing her in the final moments of the series (now internet famous) Baby Jane Doe is in the same room as her season one breakdown, telling her and herself that everything “will be okay.” “There are so many wonderful things ahead of you to see and so many people to love. There are so many wonderful things ahead of you to see. There are so many wonderful things ahead of you to love.”
While many fans of this award-winning series were expecting a big bang, they may be disappointed with this finale that is much closer to a whimper. The explosions come only from Fourth of July fireworks, which explode like distant gunshots as traumatized hospital staff hug each other and look on in stony silence. But that definitely doesn’t mean this episode is bad: 900:00 A heartbreaking meditation on new life, lives saved, and why we choose to live the lives we do.
“Do you want to know why I never killed myself?” Abbot asks Robby in the scene that will likely earn Wyle his second Emmy. “Because it’s coming for all of us, man. You and I know it better than most. We see it every shift, but we can’t get caught up in it. Yes, life can suck. It can be unbearable and ugly and heartbreaking, but it’s also beautiful and fun.” He says Robby needs someone to help him “dance in the dark.”
Does he find this in Baby Jane Doe in the final moments? Can we expect the suicidal ideation to go away by season three? Maybe. Hopefully! I don’t know! And I think this is the best.
In the past weeks fans Pitt In this final episode, they have flooded social media with increasingly far-fetched analysis that craves both grand theatricality and closure. Langdon took Whittaker’s badge (a literal dupe, of course) to gain access to the drugs. In fact, Ogilvie probably took it and heads up to the roof (wait, that sounds like too much). Or maybe it’s Santos who will die; He’s hurt himself before, have you seen the scars on his legs? (Nobody to have definitely die). Supriya Ganesh, who plays Dr Mohan, is controversially leaving the show, so I bet Mohan killed herself because of how evil Dr Robby was (stop). Also, do you think the baby really belongs to Dr Al-Hashimi? (What?)
I have nothing against fan theories. I’m such a nerd with mystery box shows like this severance pay – series that revolve around a central mystery, take big, surreal twists, and often reward viewers with frenzied Easter egg hunting. Every season, for better or worse White Lotus It encourages us to look for clues to a murder mystery by analyzing small details in recaps, podcasts, and Reddit threads.
But that’s not the point Pitt not at all, and there’s something really weird about the way a lot of fans are interacting with it.
This is a character study praised for its gritty realism; A series that tells us over and over again that the world is cruel and random, full of people doing their best to survive. The fact that the showrunners clue us in that Santos is self-harming is not the setting up of a dramatic new narrative, but a confirmation of something that has been said before: These people carry a lot of pain.
Admittedly, the show was hinting early on that something was going on with Al-Hashimi, but we got our answer to what was going on in this season’s penultimate episode when Hashimi and Dr. We got it with the dramatic confrontation between Robby and Robby. That’s enough closure for a show that’s only 15 hours long. I don’t need to see Robby kill himself or break into the therapist’s office. I don’t want some random medical student to die. And I don’t even need Mohan to decide what happens next in his career (though the actor’s departure from the show gives a clue). What they give us is enough.
Wyle, who is also the executive producer, writer and director of the series, We recently talked about the show’s fandom and we discussed how some people become overly obsessed with predicted plots, relationships, and character behaviors.
“I think audiences become knowledgeable in a whole new way when they watch a show,” he said. “They’re watching the show we’re doing, and there’s another show they’re doing. And when that show doesn’t align with the show you’re making, they don’t like it very much.”
Those making makeshift fiction about Dr Robby and Whittaker will be disappointed that their relationship remains unchanged this season. Mel and Langdon’s transportation. But it goes far beyond that. For example, Dr. Preconceptions that Robby is the ultimate Good Guy were refuted by Dr. Subverted due to his cruelty towards Mohan, which led to tremendous backlash that was reflected in Wyle himself.
“It’s a projection!” Wyle explained that the series deliberately highlights his character’s problematic traits. “He hates himself and takes it out on Mohan!”
Could the series have included more? supporting characters’ reactions to outbursts? Maybe. But I’m not mad about it Pitt – a show that can often be overly didactic in other respects – trusting the audience to notice bad behavior in the main character and think about it for themselves. He also trusts us to imagine his next steps after the credits roll.
While it may seem more common for younger (and very online) viewers these days, moral purity or demanding that our favorite shows be turned off entirely can make some TV shows incredibly boring. And this season has been a good reminder to sit back, trust the process, and loosen your grip on the things you love.
When Pitt returns next year – series creator confirms season three is coming Set four months after Robby returns from his trip (no, he didn’t adopt Baby Jane Doe) – I’ll log off, stop guessing, and take Abbot’s advice: dance in the darkness of whatever comes our way.
Pitt is currently streaming on HBO Max.
If you or someone you know needs support, call Lifeline Call 131 114 or Beyond Blue Call 1300 224 636.
Want more TV? We caught you.
Meg Watson, assistant TV editor at The Age and Sydney Morning HeraldConnect with: X or email.
