Defining the intifada and testing Australia’s racial hate laws
At its hearing on Tuesday, the Federal Court will determine what the word Intifada means to Australian Jews and whether it constitutes a crime, and the outcome of the case filed by two Sydney academics over their social media posts about the Israel-Palestine conflict.
Linguistics expert Dr. Nick Riemer and political scientist Professor John Keane are being sued over a series of posts they made on X, formerly Twitter, in a case that will test the country’s hate speech laws.
The duo claim that they are criticizing Zionism, which they claim is not antisemitic.
The group of Jewish academics who sued the duo also filed a lawsuit against their employer, the University of Sydney, claiming that they were indirectly responsible for these statements.
In the Keane case, the applicants alleged that Page
In the Riemer case, the applicants claim that posts, speeches on
A packed courtroom at Sydney’s Federal Court booed, booed and cheered at various points throughout a day-long hearing on the scope of the case on Tuesday; Federal Court Judge Geoffrey Kennett said he “feared this case could become another royal commission into antisemitism”.
Lawyer Jessie Taylor, for Riemer and Keane, said the hearing would not become another royal commission and the case was limited to whether a reasonable person would be offended by the posts.
Adam Butt, speaking on behalf of Jewish academics, said what Riemer and Keane meant by the term intifada was “completely irrelevant”.
“The only fight about what the intifada means is what it means for the Jewish people in Australia or the Israeli people. The other side of history and this conflict is completely irrelevant. My clients are not being sued for denigrating the Palestinians or any other people. What matters is the Jewish perspective,” he said.
Keane and Riemer have raised more than $173,000 in legal fees during what they say is a critical moment for free speech.
In court on Tuesday, Butt said: “This is not about Hamas’ intentions, this is about what Jews and Israelis believe.”
Riemer will hold a symposium next month on what he calls the crisis of national oppression in universities, which will “explore the authoritarian institutional responses of Australian universities to Israel’s genocide.”
The case continues.
Start your day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.


