Traditionalist Catholics face a difficult choice after Vatican cuts off breakaway group
For traditionalist Catholics who worship in churches affiliated with the schism Society of Saint Pius XSunday Service now comes with an unusual question.
Its priests and bishops were excommunicated after a fringe movement on the Catholic right committed what the Vatican considers one of the gravest crimes of the faith: breaking church unity. consecrate bishops Without the Pope’s permission. The Vatican said Catholics should stop attending worship services and activities of the breakaway group and that some rites performed by the community’s priests were illegal and invalid.
But normal life largely continues in the community’s churches. Mass in the old Latin rite is still celebrated, baptisms are held, camps and pilgrimages continue, and some believers say they have no intention of leaving.
The consecration ceremony two weeks ago sparked a crisis. Pope Leo XIV Because of its emphasis on church unity. The American pope has particularly reached out to the conservative and traditionalist wing of the church, which has been alienated in many ways during the papacy of Pope Francis.
The consequences of excommunication remain unclear
Some bishops in the United States are echoing the Vatican’s warning to the community’s faithful, urging them to convert to Roman churches.
“To embrace the unity to which Christ is called is to remain faithful to the vine and to be in communion with Pope Leo XIV and the hierarchy of the Catholic Church,” Archbishop Gustavo García-Siller of San Antonio wrote to his archdiocese.
His instruction reflects this: Declaration of division and decree of excommunication On July 2, the Vatican doctrinal office announced the opening of the St. Paul Church, also known as SSPX, where there are approximately 750 priests. A declaration issued against the Society of Pius X.
Will Catholics heed this call? It depends largely on where worshipers feel most connected, said R. Andrew Chesnut, chair of Catholic Studies at Virginia Commonwealth University.
“Long-time SSPX supporters often view such statements through the lens of a decades-long conflict with Church authorities,” he said, “and are therefore less likely to be persuaded.”
The Society was founded in opposition to the modernizing reforms of the Second Vatican Council, which it viewed as full of heresies and errors. The council in the 1960s revolutionized the church’s relations with Jews and other faiths, promoting religious freedom for all and allowing the Mass to be celebrated in people’s everyday languages rather than Latin.
SSPX leaders see the community as defiant guardians of church tradition and they defended It is stated that July 1 blessings are necessary to save souls. Society also questions the solidity of the Vatican’s sanctions.
Chesnut said the response from community leaders was “remarkably consistent” with past flare-ups with Rome. Priests reassure the faithful that there is no change in their mission to preserve the traditional Catholic liturgy.
The association appealed the Vatican decree, and US regional spokesman James Vogel said it was too early to judge its impact. For now, Masses and other activities have not stopped.
“I think a lot of people continue to stick closely to what they do,” he said.
That’s not surprising, said Mike Lewis, editor-in-chief of Where Peter Is, a Catholic commentary site that supports Pope Francis and Leo.
“We’re actually talking about communities that have been separate for 30 to 40 years. People’s families and social lives are involved in this movement,” he said.
Some traditionalist stalwarts prefer to double down
Jim De Piante’s St. His ties to the Society of Pius X run deep. His family helped bring the movement to North Carolina, and he joined St. Paul, a church affiliated with the community near Charlotte, that purchased land for a new campus a week after the excommunication. It belongs to Anthony of Padua.
On the contrary, the excommunications make him want to “make tradition more difficult.”
“St. Anthony offers me the traditional sacraments of the same faith that every great saint throughout history has done,” De Piante said. He feels it is his responsibility to preserve this belief for future generations.
While he’s not worried himself, De Piante knows others, especially new entrants, are, and he offers guidance to the SSPX that is true to its orbit. Several hundred people attended Sunday services in St. She has noticed a slight decline in attendance at St. Anthony’s and knows families who are uneasy and don’t plan to return. De Piante attended the consecration ceremonies of new bishops in Switzerland and said he remained optimistic about the future of the society.
Vatican calls on Catholics to “return home” or face consequences
When the Society of Pius The community’s faithful were also warned that they would face the church’s harshest sanctions if they “officially adhered” to the group.
Excommunication is a “medical” sanction or condemnation that can be revoked. Excommunicated people are not expelled from the church, but they are banned from some church activities.
Bishops such as Frank J. Caggiano of the Diocese of Bridgeport, Connecticut, invite the community’s churchgoers to come “home.” In a letter to his diocese, he stated that excommunication did not apply to those who accepted the pope’s authority and attended SSPX churches simply to worship.
Still, opposing the pope is no small transgression. Caggiano warned that remaining loyal to society would “mean sharing disunity with Peter’s Successor.”
Other SSPX loyalists face a ‘crisis of conscience’
Ross McKnight is struggling with what to do next.
Facing community attention during the COVID-19 pandemic, she and her family enjoy the supportive, traditionalist community of the SSPX church in nearby Lacombe, Louisiana. He thinks that many people like him are experiencing a “crisis of conscience.”
“We don’t want to leave them in their dark hours,” he said. “At the same time, this is not our first mission. The first mission does not belong to any one person and/or group of priests. So I think that is the source of the conflict.”
Texas archbishop García-Siller instructed Catholics not to join the association’s local branch and said he would no longer allow SSPX priests to preside over weddings or serve in the archdiocese.
However, livestreamed worship services are available at St. Paul’s, as in other high society churches. It also shows that church life continued at St. Joseph’s.
During the service on the first Sunday after the excommunication, the Rev. Stephen Zigrang listed more mundane announcements — building maintenance, a special collection, a baptism — before reassuring the congregation that there was no need to change course.
“The problem, of course, is family and friends,” said Zigrang, who declined an interview request from The Associated Press. “They’ll look at us crookedly. But just smile, won’t you? Say, ‘We love the old ritual…. You should come and try it.'”
___
Associated Press writer Peter Smith contributed to this report.
___
Associated Press religious coverage gets support through APs partnership With The Conversation US, funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. AP is solely responsible for this content.
