Moment sister of British woman weeps as she speaks at murder trial: Court hears how sibling was lured to US by predatory sadist who became her ‘executioner’
This is the moment the sister of a British woman wept as she spoke at her murder trial in the US.
A court heard predatory sadist Dwain Hall, 54, manipulated Sonia Exelby, 32, who was mentally ill and had suicidal fantasies, luring her to Florida so he could act as her ‘executioner’.
Ms Exelby flew from her home in Portsmouth to the US in October last year to meet Hall, a self-described ‘sadist’ who worshipped the Egyptian god of death.
The 32-year-old music tutor, who had a long history of mental health struggles, spent two years talking to Hall on a hardcore fetish website and offered to pay him to help brutally end her life.
But prosecutors allege that she got cold feet after she arrived in Florida and travelled with Hall to a remote Airbnb near the town of Reddick.
Ms Exelby’s sister tried to fight back tears and apologised as she dabbed her eyes with a tissue in court.
Gemma Isaj gave evidence just a few feet from where the man accused of killing her was sitting.
But she was reduced to tears and even said ‘sorry’ while attending the trial today before being asked whether she wanted to ‘take a break’, to which Ms Isaj responded: ‘Yes, please.’
Sonia Exelby, 32, flew from her home in Portsmouth to the US in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old self-described ‘sadist’ who worshipped the Egyptian god of death
Dwain Hall today went on trial, having pleaded not guilty to charges of murder and kidnap
Prosecutors allege Sonia got cold feet after she travelled with Hall to an Airbnb near Reddick
Sonia’s sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence just a few feet from where the accused was sitting
She took a second to compose herself before continuing to give evidence at the trial.
Ms Isaj told the court that she and Ms Exelby had a difficult childhood but said they were vert close and that once adoption happened Mr and Mrs Exelby said it was best for Sonia and Sara not to have contact at that time.
They reconnected when Ms Exelby turned 18 and ‘it was like we had never been apart’, Ms Isaj said.
The witness said she was aware of her sister’s mental health issues, telling the court Ms Exelby would open up and talk about her problems.
When she was in a ‘better place’ mentally, Ms Exelby would ‘engage’ with her but during periods when she struggled, the alleged victim would keep her at a distance, she said, and ‘would frequently pull out of plans’.
Ms Isaj said that in November 2023 she became aware of Ms Exelby’s interactions with men online:
The witness told the court: ‘She said to me that she needed to talk about something and we went and sat in another room [fighting back tears] and she told me that she had got into something and she was really terrified and that people had been making some horrible threats to her and against her family, they knew where she was and could locate her.
‘Sonia said she had gone onto some suicide forums for support and on these forums there were people that were preying on Sonia and her friends she had made online.
‘Sonia said she was trying to gather evidence because she couldn’t bear that people were being hurt and she said she needed to do this so she could gather the evidence to stop these things happening to other people.
‘I phoned the police in that moment, especially with the work I was doing I know a lot of my…I could see how scared Sonia was. I contacted the mental health crisis team and got her support.’
Recounting the events of October 10 last year, Ms Isaj said Ms Exelby was due to arrive on October 11 and had messaged to say she was ‘going to come and stay on the Friday’.
Ms Isaj said: ‘We would travel up to the airport together and we would have that weekend together to enjoy, we missed so many times that when we had those opportunities to get together to have those opportunities we really treasured.’
She said she offered to pick her sister up but Ms Exelby was ‘quite adamant’ about getting a taxi.
Ms Isaj added: ‘She said ‘I will come to airport with you on the Saturday and when it came to the Saturday she said I’m not coming to the airport, she said I will see you Sunday at 2pm.’
‘She was very specific about the time, I offered to pick her up and she said she would get a taxi – in hindsight that was a bit different.
‘I didn’t think a lot of it because it was quite usual for Sonia to not arrive, sometimes plans ebecame too much and so I sent her a message to say we would love to see her if we were able to and I would come and pick her up.’
Hall appearing in court after being accused of murdering the woman from Portsmouth
Sonia Exelby, pictured with her boyfriend Steve Hunt, flew to Florida ‘seeking a violent death’
When detectives examined Hall’s phone, they would find he had tried ‘to erase every trace of Sonia’, including numerous nude photos of her and a video he attempted to delete
Ms Isaj did not hear back and said her sister had sent a message over the weekend saying her phone was broken and she could only communicate through messenger.
Then, she added: ‘Stevie messaged me. I thought it was just for that day, then I phoned and spoke to Stevie and realised she was missing since Friday morning.’
Ms Isaj said she then contacted police immediately and posted on social media to try to reach missing persons sites in Florida.
‘We wanted to make sure to spread the word far and wide because we knew how vulnerable she was and we wanted to make sure she was found safe and well.’
Ms Isaj then became tearful as she confirmed Ms Exelby is in the still CCTV image of her arriving in Florida.
Hall is accused of pressing ahead regardless – continuing to beat and abuse Ms Exelby, before stabbing her to death.
Ms Exelby was found to have emailed herself while she was on the flight to Florida, saying: ‘As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, I can’t get off the plane, I want to beg for help so badly.
‘Oh god, I feel so sick…why am I here, why? If I wasn’t numb I would have never got out of the house, this would be impossible, although I’m hurting more than I have ever done.’
The email continued: ‘Why do I still not feel like I’m going to die… I fucked up so badly not leaving a trace at the end… If I even manage to get to him it’ll be so easy to find me I’ll be mutilated and disabled for the rest of my life.’
Hall today went on trial in the city of Ocala, Florida, having pleaded not guilty to charges of murder and kidnap.
Opening the case for the prosecution, Amy Berndt told the jury: ‘On Friday, October 10, 2025, 32-year-old Sonia Exelby flew from England to the United States.
‘By October 12, she was dead. She was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself “Alphasadist”, a man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women. That man was the defendant Dwain Hall.’
She added: ‘When he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body.’
Ms Exelby, she said, was a ‘beautiful and kind woman who was loved by everyone she knew’. She endured a difficult childhood, with her and her five siblings taken into care at a young age due to both their parents struggling with mental illness and her father having a drug problem.
She and her sister Sara were eventually adopted after three years in care and did not reconnect with their older siblings until adulthood.
‘Sonia was unable to escape the trauma of her childhood,’ the prosecutor said.
Ms Exelby suffered from bipolar disorder and bulimia and began to self-harm, ultimately making two attempts to take her own life by an overdose.
She began posting on a hardcore fetish site called Motherless, where users would upload extreme sexual imagery – including the torture and murder of women and children.
Ms Exelby spoke to many men on the website, telling them she wanted to die but knew she could not do it herself and needed help to do it. These were macabre discussions which would ‘make her feel alive’.
But one man stood out among the others, the prosecutor said, who used the online moniker ‘Alphasadist’.
‘He groomed Sonia, he wanted the job of being her executioner and that person was the defendant Dwain Hall,’ Ms Berndt said.
Ms Exelby first made an attempt to travel to meet Hall in the US in March last year, but did not manage it until October. She lied to her long-term partner Stevie Hunt that she was going to stay with her sisters that weekend.
Mr Hunt eventually found an email she sent herself from the plane ‘full of sorrow, depression, regret and death and it talked about suicide’, the prosecutor said.
He raised the alarm with British police who alerted Florida state police. Detectives in the US soon found the link to Hall after Ms Exelby’s cards were repeatedly charged by a breakdown company he owned.
Investigators would ultimately find her half-naked body buried in a shallow grave near the small suburban community of Marion Oaks – where Hall lived – with four stab wounds.
They were led there by GPS data from Hall’s phone which showed he had spent 80 minutes in the area.
It was soon established that Ms Exelby had gone to an Airbnb with Hall. He would tell detectives they had consensual rough sex inside, but denied killing her.
Investigators found that a few days after meeting Ms Exelby, Hall had posted a package to his friend in Ohio, called Rick Snider.
They raided his house and found a knife, sheath and bracelet in the package. Experts would confirm it still had Sonia’s blood on it.
When detectives examined Hall’s phone, they would find he had tried ‘to erase every trace of Sonia’, including numerous nude photos of her and a video he attempted to delete.
There was also a tranche of ‘horrific’ photos and videos showing women being tortured.
‘Evidence that the reason the defendant beat, stabbed and murdered Sonia was for his own sadistic pleasure,’ the prosecutor added.
Four of Ms Exelby’s siblings have bravely flown out to the US to come face-to-face with the man accused of her murder, after fundraising online to cover the costs.
They entered the court with their partners after the prosecutor’s opening statement, where they saw Hall sitting behind a desk in the well of the court with his attorneys, wearing a lilac dress shirt and grey trousers.
Sonia’s sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence just a few feet from where the accused was sitting.
Fighting back tears, she described how, in November 2024, Ms Exelby revealed she was ‘really terrified’ because men online were making ‘horrible threats’ against her, whom she encountered while on suicide forums seeking support.
Hall denied killing her to police, claiming he and Ms Exelby had consensual rough sex
‘On these forums there were people that were preying on Sonia and her friends she had made online. Sonia said she was trying to gather evidence because she couldn’t bear that people were being hurt and she said she needed to do this so she could gather the evidence to stop these things happening to other people,’ Ms Isaj told the court.
‘I could see how scared Sonia was.’
She said she phoned the police and contacted a mental health crisis team at the time.
On the weekend Ms Exelby flew to Florida, she had been due to meet Ms Isaj to welcome her sister Sara back from Australia, but she pulled out and messaged to say ‘I will see you Sunday at 2pm’, refusing Ms Isaj’s offer to collect her – something she now realises was unusual.
It was only when Mr Hunt contacted her on Sunday, October 12, that they realised Ms Exelby was missing.
Mr Hunt, giving evidence via a remote link from the UK, described Ms Exelby’s history of mental health issues and said after police became involved over the 2024 incident, he removed her passport and kept it in a safe place for her protection for six months.
He told the court he eventually gave it back because she was planning to go and see her sister in Australia and he ‘thought the threat of her wanting to leave was behind us’.
He described his partner of 16 years as the ‘most incredible woman I’ve ever met’ and ‘the nicest, kindest person I ever met in my life’.
Hall will not be facing the death penalty if he is convicted because British police refused to give crucial evidence to US prosecutors unless they agreed not to pursue capital punishment.
British police forces are required by law to withhold any evidence in US cases that could result in a defendant being sentenced to death.
Days before she died, Ms Exelby was said to have ‘left evidence on her computer indicating that she was again suicidal’, an earlier court hearing was told.
Investigators found that Hall had recorded footage while with Ms Exelby at the Airbnb
However, her family have claimed she was groomed through the extreme fetish website where she first met Hall.
Hall, a father-of-two, was initially arrested on suspicion of fraudulent use of credit cards and unlawful use of a two-way communication device linked to Ms Exelby.
Investigators then found that Hall had recorded footage while with Ms Exelby at the Airbnb, in which he allegedly forced her to describe in graphic detail how she wanted to die.
Ms Exelby can be seen sitting on a chair ‘looking dishevelled’ in the video, with multiple bruises across her face, neck and breasts.
Hall is heard asking her why she was in the US before she replied in tears: ‘Because I am an awful person… I’ve crushed everyone who ever loves me.’
Ms Exelby was asked ‘how’ she wanted to die and to ‘describe it’. Initially she refused to answer but eventually said she wanted ‘to be stabbed’.
She was also found to have frantically attempted to send a message to a friend via the online platform Discord during the ordeal, claiming Hall had locked her inside and would not let her leave unless she shot him.
‘I thought he’d do it quick and not give my mind time to stew,’ the message, which was not delivered, said.
‘I’m so so scared, I’m so broken and in so much pain. All I can do is lay here.’
The trial continues.
For confidential support, call Samaritans on 116 123, visit samaritans.org or visit www.thecalmzone.net/get-support




