LEE CARTER: Why a socialist became New York mayor and what it means
NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!
Zohran Mamdani became the mayor of New York City, describing himself as a socialist and leading the most capitalist city in America.
To some, this seems like evidence that the far left is taking over.
But that’s not what happens.
SOCIALIST SHOCKWAVE: ZOHRAN MAMDANI SURPRISES NYC AS VOTERS PUT THEIR POWER TO THE DEMOCRATS’ FAR LEFT WING
Mamdani didn’t win because New York suddenly fell in love with socialism.
He won because he captured something every politician needs to listen to right now: a deep frustration that the system no longer feels fair.
New York City Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani answers questions from the press at an introductory rally ahead of Election Day on Monday, Nov. 3, 2025, in Queens. (Fox News Digital/Deirdre Heavey)
And here’s the thing: This frustration isn’t limited to struggling families or low-income voters. It spreads among people who are well off; Educated, ambitious professionals who need to live their dreams but cannot escape the feeling of being left behind and trying to rise.
The New Rebellion of the Comfortable
There is a growing class of New Yorkers who don’t fit into our usual political categories. They are not the working poor or the wealthy elite. They are somewhere in between.
They’ve done everything right – the schools, the work hours, the hustle – but they still feel stuck.
Rents are rising faster than wages. Taxes eat into paychecks. Buying a house feels impossible.
They are not broken. They just burned.
They stopped believing that hard work automatically leads to stability, let alone success.
My business partner Michael Maslansky very cleverly calls them Richlanté, rich vigilantes of justice.
They don’t want help. They want honesty.
They don’t trust the system, but they still try to make it work.
Mamdani saw them before anyone else.
He didn’t speak like a career politician; He seemed like someone who truly understood their frustrations.
What Are They Actually Rebelling Against?
New York was running with ambition. It was a city of hustle and bustle that you could climb if you gave it your all.
But this promise no longer seems to be fulfilled.
New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani at the polling station inside Frank Sinatra High School for the Arts in the New York City borough of Queens on Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2025. (Getty)
Even people with good jobs feel like they’re running faster to stay where they are.
They don’t feel secure in their success. It doesn’t feel like their efforts are rewarded.
This is not guilt. This is exhaustion.
That’s regrettable for a city that once rewarded work with upward mobility and now appears to reward luck, power or connections instead.
Mamdani gave a name to this disappointment.
New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani campaigns in the Brooklyn borough of New York on Tuesday, November 4, 2025. (Adam Gray/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
He told them, “You’re right, the deal is broken. Let’s fix it.”
He did not propose a revolution. He offered recognition.
And in such a tired city, that was enough.
Trump Parallel Conservatives Should Watch Out
If this sounds familiar, it should.
Because it’s the same sentiment that powered the rise of Donald Trump.
Trump gave voice to working class Americans who felt forgotten by the elites.
Mamdani became a voice for affluent New Yorkers who felt abandoned by opportunity.
Different neighborhoods. Same feeling.
President Donald Trump gestures as he boards Air Force One for South Korea from Haneda Airport in Tokyo, Japan, on October 29, 2025. (Kim Kyung-Hoon/Pool/Anatolia via Getty Images)
Both men understood the most powerful message in politics: The system is rigged, and I’m the one who’s going to fix it.
They just offered different answers.
Trump has promised to stamp out what he sees as corruption and indifference.
Mamdani vowed to rebuild justice from scratch.
But the basic emotion of betrayal was the same.
Why Should Republicans Pay Attention?
Republicans should not dismiss Mamdani’s victory as an accident of the far left. They should look into this.
He couldn’t win because of ideology. He won because of empathy.
Because it made frustrated voters — including those making six figures — feel like their voices were being heard.
FORMER TRUMP OFFICIAL WARNED MAMDANI VICTORY WILL BE A SIGN OF ‘Marxist Change’ FOR NEW YORK CITY
That’s what conservatives do best. Ronald Reagan did this. Trump did it.
The Right spoke the language of effort, justice and dignity; If you work hard you deserve a fair chance.
President Ronald Reagan delivers remarks at a rally for Texas Republican candidates at Wild Briar Farm in Irving, Texas, on October 11, 1982. (Reagan Presidential Library)
This message still wins.
But voters don’t hear that so clearly anymore.
If the GOP can get that back — if conservatives can talk credibly about justice, not just freedom — they can reach the same voters who gave Mamdani the win.
The Big Picture
Mamdani’s victory is not proof that New York is going socialist.
New York City Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani speaks during an interview on “The Martha MacCallum Story” on Fox News on October 15, 2025 in New York City. (Evan Agostini/Invision/AP)
This is evidence that voters across income levels are tired of feeling unseen and unheard.
CLICK FOR OTHER OPINIONS OF FOX NEWS
They do not reject capitalism. They demand that he keep his promises.
They don’t want special treatment. They want fair play.
The side that first understands this and expresses it honestly will win not only New York, but also the future.
In conclusion
New York did not vote for socialism.
CLICK TO DOWNLOAD FOX NEWS APPLICATION
He voted for justice.
And this is something both parties need to take seriously; before frustration becomes the only platform for everyone to run to.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE FROM LEE CARTER
