Pakistan’s Hangor Submarine Deal With China: Who Gets The Benefit? Not The Sailor, Not The Citizen | World News
When governments offer billions of dollars of arms programs, they promise security for the nation. In theory, Hangor class submarines and subsequent relevant offers can increase Pakistan’s deterrence in the sea. In practice, however, the benefits of the Hangor agreement are probably not sailors to fold seven sea or Pakistani citizens, but often accrue to those coming from inside.
Operational risks remain
First, there is a serious doubt about whether submarines will perform at the level of sale. Open source analysts say that Hangor -class boats are export versions of China’s Yuan class and many sensitive systems have been reduced. The previously mentioned motor exchange is expected to be worse than the CHD620 diesel war submarines, and Hangor’s noise profile will be worse than India’s new Scorpene.
Add Zee News as a preferred resource
Also read: Meet the Hangor class submarine that China delivered to Pakistan; Can he survive in India’s killing area?
Oceans do not forgive and a noisy submarine is a fundamental mismatch with the alleged strategic edge that is easily identified. In short, the crew can find that the latest technology of the crew is not the latest technology. History shows that design defects or compatibility problems often occur only in the sea years later. If Hangors face mechanical teething or sensor gaps (as in Thailand’s similar S26 subs), sailors will carry the burden of failure. The repair of a submarine in the service means to direct the scarce budget to unplanned corrections by placing in friendly areas, or to confuse dry docks in seven sea -friendly areas in a world where allies around the world see a decrease. The training programs imported within the scope of the contract may have to struggle to address the unpredictable problems. During this time, lives may be in a crisis. A flawed subfesin is not the advocate of the nation; This is a tiring responsibility.
National book and hungry people
Likewise, Pakistan’s Hangora cannot get so many spending. Islamabad approved an unusual federal budget, while total expenditures decreased by about 7%, while defense expenditures increased by 20%. In absolute sense, some PKR was allocated to the army of 2.55 trillion (approximately $ 9 billion). The share of the navy – approximately 266 billion PKR (941 million dollars) – includes HANGOR PAYMENTS and corresponding costs. In contrast, each social program sits on the chopping block. Great interruptions in subsidies, health, education and infrastructure are discussed, under the serious pressure of Pakistan IMF and other creditors.
Also read: from Karachi to Ormara: Pakistan’s Hangor submarines should survive before opposing India
This exchange comes with Pakistan’s struggling with a food crisis; Roughly, one of the six Pakistanis, according to UNICEF, is now insecure food; Inflation is at the highest level of crises and public nutritional indicators deteriorate. The limited financial area means that the government cannot meet strong social security networks. Nevertheless, billions of rupees are flowing into an unknown defense project with full cost and effectiveness. Billions are attributed to opaque agreements, but are covered by ordinary taxpayers who see the reduction of investment in cost, food, energy and social services. Economically, every rupee that covers the pockets of the inside is a ruup that can feed a malnutrored child or run a hospital.
Defending advantages on people
Finally, you need to ask – who really defends this? If corporate benefits are any guide, the answer is not people. Pakistani regularly reports that civil society reported, great defense supplies are divided into a tenant class. 2025 OP-ED left it naked by Sakariya Kareem in Asia Lite: The military organization said, “It is undoubtedly the deepestly established institutional caries source, maintained by power protected by power”. According to this view, national security is usually interpreted as securing the privileges of a few of them, including housing projects in door -wing generations, overseas bank accounts and control of profitable industries.
This mentality continues unless there is a civil surveillance that Pakistan has been missing since its independence. In contrast, an honest assessment will accept that human safety involves feeding hungry and educating young people. An IMF -supported reform agenda emphasizes the reduction of poverty and health investment. However, when more budget is directed to HANGOR and other weapons, these goals are withdrawn. Despite the supreme strategic arguments, the Hangor agreement becomes a situation in which Pakistan’s defense really serves the defense of the advantages of the defense of Pakistan. Seafarers who manage these submarines will know better; If the boats are noisy and are not trusted, the cold corruption account will fail them from the inside. And citizens will remember that when Levies climb and cereal prices rise, they are not the money paid for the invisible commissions under the waves, but their money.
In the end, a single note consists of people, not from land barriers or hand -drawn maps. A country is above all a human being. And if people do not have food or clothing clothes to eat, the type of space that cannot pass the shipyard is not good for the country. As Freud said, if the identity is met, with the ego and superego tag.
