Top Bupa staff awarded $14m in bonuses despite insurer admitting to misleading thousands of Australians | Executive pay

Senior Australian health insurance staff at Bupa were given bonuses of more than $14 million just over a year ago after the company admitted unscrupulously causing customers to cancel or delay medical procedures.

The bonuses, awarded to more than 20 staff in 2023-24, came after the insurer engaged in “misleading and deceptive conduct” between May 2018 and August 2023. This affected more than 7,500 customers, leaving many out of pocket for procedures they were entitled to request.

bupa Admitted misconduct in June 2025 We reached an agreement with Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) will pay a fine of $35 million. The $14.1 million bonus represents 40% of the proposed fine.

The federal court has not yet decided whether the sentence is appropriate.

Bupa admits this misled thousands of members into believing they did not have insurance for certain medical treatments over a five-year period. Some customers upgraded their insurance when they didn’t need it, according to the ACCC.

When the proposed $35 million fine was first announced, Bupa’s chief executive, Nick Stone, said: “We are deeply sorry we failed to do things right for our customers and regret the impact this has had on them and their families. This should never have happened.”

The ACCC said at the time that some Bupa customers were “delaying, canceling or failing to receive treatment for which they were at least partially covered by their health insurance policy”.

A. Document outlining Bupa’s commitments to the ACCC It shows the insurer voluntarily implemented a “recovery program” to address losses incurred in 2021, three years before bonuses were due to be paid. The document also shows Bupa co-operated with the ACCC’s investigation for four years and the case was eventually brought to court.

_{Sign up: AÜ Breaking News email}

As of June 30, the insurance company had so far paid $14.3 million in compensation to people affected by 4,100 misjudged claims.

Corporate disclosures reveal that Bupa’s health insurance executives had already been rewarded millions of dollars by then for the company’s “strong improvements in both business results and customer experience.”

Bupa’s bonuses are just one example of bonuses awarded to senior employees despite public outrage and regulatory sanctions over their companies’ actions.

Qantas has faced pressure to cut generous bonuses after a federal court found it had illegally dismissed 1,800 workers. So is childcare giant G8 Education, whose chief executive received a $534,426 short-term bonus last year despite numerous safety breaches and the employment of a man who was later accused of multiple child sex crimes.

Corporate law expert Helen Bird, a senior lecturer at Swinburne University, said bonuses were key to determining an organisation’s culture and what behavior was acceptable.

“If you want to know how a company is really run, you have to understand how it rewards its managers,” Bird said.

Million-dollar jackpot ‘sends the wrong message’

During the 2023-24 financial year, a senior Bupa employee was awarded a $2.5 million annual bonus, with a $2 million payment deferred to a later year. The bonus was more than double the position’s $1.1 million salary.

The other 19 executives shared a total bonus of $11.6 million, of which $5.5 million was deferred to subsequent years.

The bonuses were announced by Australian Consumer Health Forum chief executive Dr. It was condemned by Elizabeth Deveny, who said “it is quite difficult to believe that these executive bonuses are in line with society’s expectations.”

“When a company violates consumer trust, multimillion-dollar executive bonuses send the wrong message,” Deveny said. “This reinforces the perception that profits come before people.

“I imagine there are a lot of people whose claims were mistakenly denied and who are scratching their heads asking themselves why these bonuses were deserved.”

A Bupa spokesman repeated the insurer’s apology and said the breaches “were not the result of any individual’s actions or decisions, but resulted from cumulative errors in our systems, processes and training of our employees.”

“A significant portion of total executive compensation is based on criteria that are tightly linked to the performance of the business,” the spokesman said.

Bupa also said bonuses were being cut in response to the ACCC’s action. It is not known whether this includes clawback provisions for deferred bonus payments.

Many of the employees subject to ACCC proceedings no longer work for Bupa.

“In line with our approach to executive remuneration and the accountability framework, we have taken appropriate action in response to these issues,” the spokesman said.

“This includes disciplinary action and/or financial penalties where appropriate.”

Until 2024, companies like Bupa would not be required to disclose executive bonuses. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, “Shedding additional light on how managers are incentivized and the consequences of poorly managed risks”.

Australian Medical Association president Dr Danielle McMullen did not criticize Bupa directly but said she remained concerned about executive pay at the expense of patient outcomes.