‘Desperately unfair’ shortcuts to be banned for exams
VCE students will be banned from using certain formulas and features on advanced model calculators in maths exams from next year.
The Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority (VCAA) has said Computer Algebra System (CAS) calculators, long controversial in maths teaching circles, will be allowed into VCE exam halls but advanced shortcut functions will be banned.
Under the new rules, only CAS calculators that can program shortcuts to complete relevant calculations more quickly and disable “user-defined functions” (UDFs) that provide steps for procedures will be allowed into testing areas, and student use will be closely supervised by invigilators during the day.
The authority said it would implement the change for the 2027 exam cycle after consulting hundreds of teachers and students. But the move falls short in NSW and Queensland, where exam authorities have imposed outright bans on calculators.
“Following wide-ranging consultation, the VCAA will require special functions, including User Defined Functions (UDFs) on Computer Algebra System (CAS) calculators to be restricted during VCE Maths exams from 2027,” a spokesman for the authority said.
“As technologies evolve, VCAA proactively points out the importance of students engaging with their teachers on the foundational math skills outlined in their study designs.”
CAS calculators will only be allowed in “restricted mode”, which prevents the use of advanced features.
The exam authority has confirmed that the list of approved calculators will be sent to schools before the end of this term.
Schools and students will be given detailed instructions on how to disable the functions after this year’s VCE exams.
Greg Ashman, deputy principal and maths teacher at VCE’s powerful Ballarat Clarendon College, said the change was long overdue.
“It’s one of the best ideas I’ve heard in a long time,” he said of the move. “If I had my way, exams would be paper and pencil.”
Ashman called supercalculators “deeply unfair” because young people who could write code or download programs to add to the devices had an advantage over others.
“Using them still requires knowledge and mathematical understanding; it does not completely replace thinking, but it is not fair as some students may program them to a degree that is advantageous,” he said.
The teacher said VCAA has a “clear-eyed” and optimistic view of technology, instead focusing in the past on ensuring young people develop mathematical knowledge rather than just calculator-using skills.
Other experts wanted to know how the VCAA plans to police enforcement in the exams and believe the changes do not go far enough.
Professor Burkard Polster, from Monash University’s School of Mathematics, questioned how students could be monitored to ensure they were not using the functions and called for a complete ban on calculators.
“It’s hard to restrict and enforce anything, even if they have to buy a new calculator, but even that doesn’t stop people from getting around these tricks. [the rule] and I do fancy things,” he said.
Polster said that thanks to these calculators, some students can get exam answers with a single click, while others can take the exam in a longer time and do everything from scratch.
“It’s not a level playing field right now,” he said of current calculators.
Polster added that this also causes problems for students who go to college to study engineering, mathematics or other STEM fields because they lack a basic understanding of mathematics.
In March, the VCAA sent a letter. AgeTo managers who accept the complexity of user-defined functions that can be downloaded into CAS calculators.
“[They] The letter states that the calculators enable a wider and more advanced range of functionality than is available in ‘native’ or ‘factory’ settings.
It was stated that the complexity of the calculations had prompted the VCAA to consider whether additional checks were required to support basic knowledge and mathematical skills in the exams.
Start your day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

