Non-crime hate incident recording system for police ‘not fit for purpose’ – UK politics live | Politics

Good morning. With just two days to go before Christmas, the normally robust flow of news from Westminster has all but subsided. There’s not much on the government’s agenda today other than an announcement about a scheme to see young people leaving care in England get free prescriptions and free dental and vision services until their 25th birthday, which we write about here…

…and also confirmation that some former mineworkers will receive a £100-a-week increase in their pensions as a result of the change announced in the budget to the British Coal Staff Pension Scheme.

Children’s minister Josh MacAlister is being interviewed about the care leavers announcement this morning.

We’re in one of those weeks where news organizations, more than ever, are having to come up with their own stories. We received a report in politics Peter Walker The reform is about a plan to cut the UK’s aid spending (or, more accurately, cut it more than it has already been cut).

“Reform plans to cut the UK’s aid budget by 90% will not match current contributions to global organizations such as the UN and the World Bank, fragmenting the UK’s international influence and risking its position within those organisations, charities and other parties, Peter writes.

Telegram Bouncing Open a story with Charles Hymasinternal affairs editor, “hate incidents other than crime [NCHIs] “They will be scrapped as part of plans that police chiefs will submit to the home secretary next month.” This is No. 2026. It sounds like something written for the 10 news network, but Hymas spoke Lord HerbertThe former Conservative policing minister and now president of the College of Policing, an organization that works with the Home Office on policing policy, has confirmed that NCHIs work. He told the newspaper:

NCHIs will go as a concept. That system will be thrown away and replaced with a completely different system.

There will be no record of anything like this in criminal databases. Instead, only the most serious category of what would be considered anti-social behavior will be recorded. It’s a sea change.

Police started recording NCHIs following a recommendation. William Macpherson1999 report on the murder of Stephen Lawrence. Macpherson said police should create “a comprehensive system for reporting and recording all racist incidents and crimes”.

Herbert He told the Telegraph that the system was no longer “fit for purpose” due to the growth of social media and the advent of smartphones. He said:

This draws the police into territory that I believe they do not want to be in. The police have been caricatured as wanting to get involved, but I haven’t come across any police who do this.

While some police officers claim that recording NCHIs is a useful way of recording criminal behavior, the system has also produced numerous stories (particularly in the Telegraph) about police forces being overly preoccupied with offensive tweets.

Under the new system, officers will not record incidents of hate speech in crime databases, but will instead treat them as intelligence reports, according to the Telegraph. They will also be given a “common sense” checklist so they can only intervene in cases of serious anti-social behaviour. Herbert told the paper that police had to be careful not to “throw the baby out with the bath water.”

Ministers including Keir Starmer and home secretary Shabana Mahmood have said (normally in response to media reports about allegations of police overreaction to NCHIs) that they want the police to focus on things that matter to the public, and the Telegraph says the Policing College plans are likely to be accepted by the Home Office. Mahmoud like that It was recorded as he said police must be able to distinguish between “content” and “content” [on social media] It is aggressive, rude, rude and incites violence and incitement to hatred.”

There’s not much in the diary for today. But we will find some news somewhere.

If you would like to contact me, please message below the line during comments open hours (normally between 10am and 3pm currently) or message me on social media. I can’t read all messages BTL, but if you type “Andrew” in a message addressed to me, I’m more likely to see it because I’m looking for posts containing that word.

If you want to flag something urgently, it’s best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn.bsky.social. The Guardian has stopped posting from their official account on

I find it very helpful for readers to point out errors, even minor typos. No mistake is too small to be corrected. I also find your questions very interesting. I can’t promise to respond to them all, but I will try to respond as much as I can, either on BTL or sometimes on the blog.