‘He’s not been great by any yardstick’: Readers weigh up Starmer’s future ahead of crucial local elections

KLabor Party is preparing for a historic collapse in local elections Independent Readers are grappling with a bigger question than Thursday’s results: Will anything – even a wipeout – be enough to get Sir Keir Starmer out?

Many commentators see the election as a verdict on Starmer’s leadership, arguing that Labor has failed to connect with voters and risks losing ground not only to the Greens and Liberal Democrats, but also in traditional strongholds of Reform UK.

There is a strong sense of disappointment, particularly among those reacting to Dan Haygarth’s reporting from St Helens, where some lifelong Labor voters say they feel abandoned and no longer represented by the party.

At the same time, others have noted warnings from Professor Sir John Curtice that although Starmer’s position looks increasingly fragile, he may still survive in the short term as he has no obvious successor. This uncertainty continues in our community, and readers question whether relocating it will actually change anything.

Meanwhile, the projected increase for the Reformation looms large; many readers warn that frustrated voters could push politics further to the right, potentially deepening Labor’s losses in areas where it can least afford to lose.

Here’s what you need to say:

My support for Labor has wavered but I still won’t vote for Reform

My wife and I, who are both retired, have come a long way pushing Labor Party leaflets through doors during the pre-election campaign.

Almost the first thing they did was threaten PIP, which our son depends on for any kind of independence. Even conservatives never did that. Due to side effects of medications and long-term brain damage, he has poorly controlled epilepsy. However, because he was physically able to go to the toilet on his own, his PIP was threatened. It wasn’t considered a big deal that he needed someone else in the house if he had a seizure in the bathroom, which he often did.

We are devastated that they appear to be trying so hard not to upset Daily Mail readers that, in true Tory style, they are going after the weakest. However, in response to this, I cannot understand or forgive those who voted for Reform, which is further to the right than the Conservative Party that caused all this mess in the first place. I’ll vote for whoever I need to keep them out.

Brandon26

Voting would be better without Starmer

The election reality is that Labor polls will improve if Starmer goes before the next general election and, for example, Burnham becomes party leader and therefore Prime Minister for a while. Labor will also be in a position to discuss with the Greens which seats they will and will not fight each other on.

Burnham is the person who can lead us to a corruption-free social democratic success story where family is redefined but also embraced. A country that offers opportunities to those who deserve them, not to those who are better connected. We also work with the EU on our own military industrial base. As the US gets rid of Trump and the GOP, it will retreat back into isolationism, so we need to consider the unthinkable like deals with China.

A Little Drunk Max

The only man who can lead Labor to victory

To give an example as a retired teacher, if a school was in trouble, a talented super-head would be assigned to steer the ship. This was someone with years of experience in how schools should be run, as well as expert knowledge of the education system. But most of all, he was a person who could lead and command the respect of both teachers and students.

With this in mind, there is only one man who can do all this and more. If Labor has any chance of winning the next election, there’s only one man who needs to lead it and that’s Andy Burnham.

Laertes

Worker inherits a full dog’s breakfast

I understand people’s frustration, but Labor inherited a dog’s breakfast from the Conservatives and Trump’s petty tariff dodge, and now attacks on Iran have rattled the world economy and sent fuel prices into the stratosphere. In the short term no one else or no party will be able to repair the damage and Reform’s plan will destroy the NHS and bankrupt the country. The Conservatives are clueless and although the Liberal Democrats and Greens have some good ideas they are unproven in government. The only area where I would question Starmer’s direction is that he has moved too slowly to adopt EU standards. Our future is in Europe, and we may not be able or ready to rejoin the EU, but we must move closer to the EU as quickly as possible.

BlindPew

See Clacton

Those who are spending more time and energy opposing Starmer and everything else would do well to take a closer look at themselves, because no matter who the Prime Minister is, only a united party will bring about the change the country desperately needs. Ego-driven MPs who prioritize their own interests are also partly responsible for this confusion.

Those who seriously believe that voting for inexperienced Reform candidates will bring about change for the better are more than delusional (see Clacton). Farage is a merchant of chaos. He is only interested in using whatever is available to retain power and increase his own wealth, as those who support him will find out too late. The more Reform councilors elected this week, the less likely there will be increased alignment with the EU, because no one in the EU can afford to risk further entanglement with a country where there is a risk of Farage being in power after the next General Election!

Ambigirls

Westminster’s opposing duopoly designed to fail

This is a classic mistake; It is the organization that is to blame, not the leader. John Major is right to think that changing the leader will make things better; five Prime Ministers in ten years have not made people’s lives nearly five times better. The team is responsible for delivery, not the team leader. In this respect, Westminster’s opposition duopoly is designed to fail. People more interested in their own careers than serving voters need not apply.

FreeLife

What does the Labor Party represent?

I waited ten years for a Labor government in the hope that they would fix the wreckage of the Tory government. What the country is left with is a collection of government sickles with no connection to the people, and a public with little understanding of what Labor currently stands for. Ministers have striven to make a positive difference on the issues people care about: health, education, defence, immigration, crime, tax, welfare. It is always said that we will see the results of the problems they claim to be advancing in 2029-30. The common ground between the generations now appears to have no connection with the Labor Party.

sinking feeling

Not everything is the government’s fault

One of the biggest problems we face (like other countries) is that the not-so-smart among us (there are many) think that if things don’t go their way, it’s the government’s fault. The credit crisis, Brexit, Putin, Trump, Covid, Johnson, Truss and unions have made managing the economy very difficult. It doesn’t help to have the likes of Farage and Polanski around.

A lot

Local elections are not referendums

If the people of St Helens want the old Labor Party, the last thing they need is Farage, quite the opposite. They must have forgotten what the old Labor Party was all about.

Local elections are not a referendum on the central government or the Prime Minister; these relate to planning, rubbish collection and your local council swimming pool (if you still have one).

hera

A worrying trend

He is not a perfect person by any criteria, but it is a worrying trend that voters choose a party expecting a particular Prime Minister, and parties do a bit of bait-and-switching every year.

I was glad to see the back of Johnson, who was immensely relieved when Truss’ end came; However, while we think that no matter which party is in the government, they can change the Prime Minister as they wish, we should not ignore the fact that this is a step in the wrong direction.

SeanF

Starmer needs to go

Starmer needs to go, no ifs or buts; It is the responsibility of the Labor Party.

Those who think reform is the solution need to think again. They are full of former Tories who jumped ship when they realized the Conservatives were going to lose the last general election, which they did.

I think Starmer will resign, Andy Burnham or Angela Rayner will become Prime Minister, and Labor’s poll ratings will rise significantly.

The 2029 general election is still three years away and frankly I don’t think Farage will become Prime Minister, at least I hope not.

Christopher1959

I want to share your opinions? To log in or register simply click ‘sign in’ or ‘sign up’ in the top right corner. Once you sign up, you can comment on the day’s top stories to showcase your views.

Want your voice to stand out? Independent Bonus Subscribers have priority in featured comments. Subscriber Here.

Be sure to follow our community guidelines, which you can find at. Here. For a complete guide on how to comment, Click here.