The Christmas TV adverts that would NEVER air today – after John Lewis received criticism over its portrayal of ‘spoilt brat’ grandchildren
John Lewis’s Christmas adverts are almost as eagerly anticipated as December 25 itself – but this year’s offering left some viewers feeling furious as opposed to festive.
The ad, starring Dame Kristin Scott Thomas, tells the story of a grandmother, Gloria, who struggles to connect with her unruly young grandchildren… until she splashes out on decorations and disco lights from the middle class department store to win them over.
Critics have accused the British retailer of rewarding bad behaviour and promoting materialism.
John Lewis, however, insists that the advert was intended to encourage shoppers to put more thought into their Christmas presents.
A spokesman for the retailer wrote: ‘Gifting across generations can feel tricky, and it’s so tempting to just hand over an envelope of cash to play it safe. We hope Gloria’s story inspires everyone to back their instincts and choose something personal this Christmas.’
But it’s not the first Christmas advert that has been accused of missing the point of the festive season – or spoiling it altogether.
From swapping Baby Jesus for a sausage roll to watching a woman give birth live on stage, and supposedly promoting ‘veganism’, here are nine other adverts that brought out viewers’ inner Grinch.
Iceland’s ‘too political’ Christmas advert (2018)
Iceland’s 2018 Christmas advert followed its pledge to remove palm oil from all of its own-brand food
In 2018, budget supermarket Iceland ditched the prawn rings for activism with an animated Christmas advert – only to land on advertising chiefs’ naughty list.
Narrated by actress Emma Thompson, the 90-second film featured a young orangutan called Rang-tan who turns up in a child’s bedroom to explain how its rainforest home is being destroyed to produce palm oil, an ingredient found in everything from food to shampoo.
The advert followed Iceland’s pledge to remove palm oil from all its own-brand food by the end of the year amid growing concerns about deforestation in South East Asia.
But advertising chiefs refused to allow it on TV because the film had originally been made by environmental campaign group Greenpeace.
Under broadcasting rules, adverts cannot be ‘inserted by or on behalf of a body whose objects are wholly or mainly of a political nature’.
Clearcast, which approves adverts for broadcast, said Greenpeace had failed to prove it wasn’t a political organisation.
Aldi’s alcoholic carrot (2017)
Just one complaint triggered an investigation by the ASA into Aldi’s 2017 Christmas advert
Home Alone has Kevin McCallister and Aldi has Kevin the Carrot – two figures synonymous with Christmas chaos.
While the former is a dab hand at laying booby traps, the latter is more likely to be found dodging sharp cutlery (and teeth) as he cavorts around the dinner table with his fresh produce aisle pals.
But according to advertising chiefs, he’s also got the potential to encourage children to take an interest in booze.
Aldi introduced Kevin in 2016, but it was a separate 20-second clip promoting the supermarket’s spirits range at Christmas in 2017 that landed him in hot water.
The cartoon carrot starred in a parody of the 1999 horror film The Sixth Sense, declaring: ‘I see dead parsnips,’ before being frightened by a ghost.
Just one complaint from a viewer concerned about the advert’s appeal to children was enough to trigger an investigation by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA).
In February 2018, the watchdog ruled that Kevin’s childlike voice, nursery rhyme-style narration and popularity as a cuddly toy meant the alcohol advert was likely to appeal strongly to under-18s.
Despite Aldi arguing that the film was intended for adults, the ASA banned it from being shown again in its original form.
It was a decision that really grated fans… but no doubt left one vengeful vegetable-phobe very happy.
Waitrose’s soldier returning home (2009)
In 2009, Waitrose was accused of ‘commercially trading on the goodwill the public have for the armed forces’ after featuring an apparent military homecoming in its Christmas advert.
The sentimental advert featured people making their way home for Christmas, including a student on a train, a family in a car and a man arriving at a port, interspersed with shots of Waitrose’s Christmas food.
But it was a scene of a man stepping out of a Chinook helicopter carrying presents which triggered outrage.
Although the posh supermarket later insisted the man was a photojournalist rather than a serviceman, critics blasted the advert as insensitive to families of British troops who were serving in Iraq and Afghanistan – and those who had lost loved ones in the conflicts.
The advert’s slogan, ‘This Christmas, there’s only one place to be’, was particularly unfortunate given that thousands of British troops were spending the festive season away from their families.
Colonel Bob Stewart, chairman of Action for Armed Forces, said at the time: ‘I do think this is a bit insensitive, both to the families of those who have been killed and to those troops who are still out there.’
Following complaints, Waitrose removed the helicopter scene, saying: ‘We would never wish to cause distress to anyone,’ but admitted it could have been interpreted differently.
Edeka’s ‘hidden Nazi symbols’ (2016)
The advert was intended to encourage parents to spend less time worrying about Christmas preparations
Edeka’s advert appeared to contain secret Nazi references
In 2016, German supermarket Edeka came under fire after eagle-eyed viewers spotted what appeared to be secret Nazi references in its Christmas advert.
The sentimental film featured a stressed mother rushing around trying to get everything ready for Christmas, from shopping to decorating, while her increasingly neglected children longed for some attention.
But the heartwarming campaign, designed to encourage parents to spend less time worrying about Christmas preparations and more time with their families, caused outrage.
Critics spotted two car number plates in the clip which they claimed contained hidden messages linked to Adolf Hitler and the Nazis.
Extremism expert Sabine Bamberger-Stemmann was among those who raised concerns about the apparent far-Right symbolism.
One number plate read ‘MU SS 420’; critics claimed that the ‘SS’ – a letter combination banned from German cars – referenced Hitler’s notorious paramilitary organisation, the Schutzstaffel. Furthermore, they claimed that ‘420’ potentially represented April 20 – the dictator’s birthday.
Another number plate read ‘SO LL 3849’, which critics claimed also contained far-Right symbolism. The numbers 8 and 4 represent the letters H and D – short for ‘Heil Deutschland’, or ‘Hail Germany’.
Meanwhile, the surrounding numbers 3 and 9 were interpreted as C and I, standing for ‘Christian Identity’, a movement associated with white supremacy and antisemitism.
The supermarket denied deliberately slipping Nazi references into its festive campaign, insisting the number plates were made-up combinations designed to fit the advert’s Christmas message.
Edeka said it regretted any offence or misunderstanding caused.
Mr Kipling’s ‘Nativity’ (2003)
Mr Kipling’s 2003 advert was a strange twist on a nativity play
Mr Kipling’s 2003 Christmas advert began with a close-up of a woman named Mary screaming in agony in what appeared to be a hospital labour ward.
However, as the camera panned out, it was revealed she was actually giving birth to a baby girl live on stage in a church hall, in an unsettling twist on a child’s nativity play.
As the stunned audience looked on, someone asked the vicar: ‘Has Mr Kipling ever directed a nativity play before?’ to which he replied: ‘No, but he does make exceedingly good cakes.’
A spokesman for Mr Kipling’s parent company, Manor Bakeries, said the campaign was a ‘light hearted take on the traditional nativity show that so many families enjoy at this time of year’.
But viewers were far from amused, branding the advert blasphemous. It attracted 806 complaints, according to the Advertising Standards Authority’s (ASA) 2004 annual report.
Thankfully for the viewers left choking on their festive food, the advert was only aired three times before it was pulled.
Asda’s ‘mum does all the work’ (2012)
The 2012 Christmas advert was accused of dragging gender equality back to the 1950s
In 2012, ASDA’s Christmas advert was accused of peddling sexist tropes after suggesting that mums were responsible for doing absolutely everything in the run-up to the big day.
The campaign featured an increasingly exhausted mother rushing around shopping, cleaning, cooking, writing cards, wrapping presents and preparing the house for Santa’s arrival.
Meanwhile, her husband appeared largely useless, eventually asking his exhausted wife: ‘What’s for tea, love?’
The advert ended with the slogan: ‘Behind every great Christmas there’s mum, and behind every mum there’s Asda.’
Critics accused the supermarket of dragging gender equality back to the 1950s, portraying women as domestic slaves and men as lazy, incompetent fathers who couldn’t even be trusted to open a box of mince pies.
The backlash prompted Fathers 4 Justice to complain. Others argued the advert was insensitive to single dads and children who had lost their mothers.
In total, the ASA received 620 complaints, making it one of the most complained-about adverts of 2012.
But despite the backlash, Asda refused to back down, insisting that its advert reflected the reality of Christmas for millions of women.
In January 2013, the advertising watchdog sided with Asda, ruling that the advert was unlikely to cause serious or widespread offence.
BBC ‘pro-vegan turkeys’ (2019)
The feature film was criticised by the National Farmers’ Union
In 2019, the National Farmers’ Union (NFU) was spitting feathers when the BBC aired a Christmas advert that appeared to show turkeys promoting veganism.
The surreal festive film, introduced by Graham Norton, featured a series of quirky scenes, including a man dressed as a Christmas tree and an elderly relative promising not to talk about politics.
But it was a group of animated turkeys wearing ‘I love vegans’ Christmas jumpers which caused a stir.
The birds were seen celebrating the news that ‘less of us have been gobbled this year’, alongside images of meat-free Christmas dinners.
The NFU accused the broadcaster of promoting veganism and showing bias against British livestock farmers.
The union argued that the publicly funded broadcaster had breached its own impartiality rules by appearing to take sides in the debate over meat consumption.
A BBC spokesman said the birds were meant to be ‘comedic and playful’ rather than ‘any kind of endorsement or encouragement of a vegan lifestyle’.
The BBC subsequently rejected the complaint, insisting the advert did not breach its impartiality rules.
Harvey Nichols’ ‘Walk of shame’ (2011)
Harvey Nichols’ 2011 attracted controversy with critics accusing the advert of reinforcing sexist stereotypes and shaming women for casual sex
While most Christmas adverts feature heartwarming family reunions, Harvey Nichols celebrated another aspect of the festive season – going out.
The cheeky 2011 campaign featured a series of dishevelled women making the dreaded ‘walk of shame’ home following a night out.
Still wearing the previous night’s skimpy party dresses and high heels, the women were seen creeping through the streets in broad daylight, desperately avoiding the disapproving stares of commuters as they nursed a pounding head.
So far, so relatable. But the advert ended with a glamorous woman confidently striding home, looking immaculate in an outfit from Harvey Nichols – suggesting that a sufficiently expensive dress could spare women the embarrassment of the morning after.
The retailer even encouraged viewers to share their own morning-after horror stories on Twitter using the hashtag #walkofshame. However, not everyone appreciated the joke.
Critics accused Harvey Nichols of reinforcing sexist stereotypes, shaming women for having casual sex and suggesting that those who could afford designer clothes were somehow superior to those who couldn’t.
The ASA received seven complaints, including one claiming that a woman’s ripped tights could be interpreted as suggesting sexual violence.
The watchdog investigated whether the advert was offensive, demeaning to women or made unfair distinctions based on social class.
Harvey Nichols defended the campaign, saying it was intended to ‘raise a smile by reminding people of a familiar hazard of the Christmas party season’.
In March 2012, the watchdog rejected the complaints, ruling that the advert was neither sexist nor demeaning and did not breach advertising rules.
Greggs’ Nativity (2017)
Greggs’ controversial 2017 Christmas campaign saw them swap out Jesus for a sausage roll
There is no mention of puff pastry anywhere in the Bible – and it most certainly doesn’t feature in the Nativity.
So when Greggs swapped out Baby Jesus for a sausage roll in its 2017 Christmas campaign, there was outcry.
To promote its £24 advent calendar, the high street bakery shared an image of the Three Wise Men gathered around a manger, cooing not at the son of God, but at one of the brand’s most popular savouries – which cost just 90p at the time.
It sparked outrage among religious campaigners who accused Greggs of mocking Christianity.
Greggs eventually apologised, with a spokesman saying: ‘We’re really sorry to have caused any offence, this was never our intention.’
It was also pointed out the irony of replacing Jesus – who was Jewish and is also revered as a prophet in Islam – with a pork sausage roll, given that eating pork is forbidden in both religions.




