Burnham insists EU surrender summit is ‘good day’ despite being hit with brutal ambush by Brussels … as he asks European chiefs to ‘brainstorm’ on UK rejoining
Andy Burnham has hailed a ‘good day’ at the EU summit despite being hit with a brutal last-minute ambush.
The PM said he had agreed a ‘win-win’ package for both sides after taking a host of Cabinet ministers to Brussels, claiming it would add £17billion to the UK economy by 2040.
He also appealed for EU commission chief Ursula von der Leyen to work with him in an ‘informal brainstorming process’ about how the UK might rejoin the bloc.
At a joint press conference, Mr Burnham argued that polls showed three-quarters of Brits wanted closer relations.
‘We have delivered that better deal,’ he said. ‘This is a good day for Britain and this is a good day for Europe. The agreement that we’ve reached today is a win-win.’
Ms von der Leyen described the pact as a ‘turning point’. ‘We are open for brainstorming and we welcome this brainstorming,’ she added.
There was already alarm that Mr Burnham is taking the bloc’s rules on food, contributing cash and permitting ‘free movement’ for around 100,000 European 20-somethings every year.
But in a negotiating twist, EU officials warned this morning that the terms might not be implemented unless Mr Burnham caves to demands to slash tuition fees for students.
They are setting a six-month deadline for resolving that element, with none of the rest of the package guaranteed until then. Giving EU students domestic rates could cost the taxpayer nearly £500million a year.
No10 sources insisted the issues were not linked. But a draft statement circulated to EU ambassadors suggested otherwise.
Asked about his ‘bumpy’ morning, Mr Burnham provoked laughter from journalists as he claimed there was ‘no confusion’. ‘The deal is done. It’s there in black and white in front of you,’ he said, confirming that legislation will be presented to Parliament next week.
Ms von der Leyen tried to sweep away the concerns by saying the tuition fee debate was ‘on a different sheet of paper’ and she was confident ‘solutions’ would be found.
European Council president Antonio Costa dodged a direct question about whether the other deals could go ahead without a resolution on tuition fees.
He said they needed to give ‘more opportunities… especially to the young generations’. ‘It is our duty to open to them new opportunities,’ he added.
One Labour veteran said the last-minute assault might ‘make Andy think twice about rejoining’.
At a joint press conference, Andy Burnham argued that polls showed three-quarters of Brits wanted closer relations with the EU
Andy Burnham was greeted warmly by EU Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and Council president Antonio Costa today – but at the same time the bloc was playing hardball on the terms of the ‘reset’
As Mr Burnham was welcomed with a kiss by Ms von der Leyen, EU officials were briefing that the agreement might not go ahead unless he caves on demands to cut tuition fees
Mr Burnham was joined by ministers including Chancellor John Healey, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband and Environment Secretary Angela Eagle for the summit talks today
Mr Costa also referred to the longer-term prospect of Britain rejoining the bloc, saying: ‘You are always welcome in the European Union.’
‘We remain open to have the closest possible relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union,’ he added.
Mr Burnham signalled that there would be no more incremental deals, and the next year would be spent thrashing out more fundamental options.
‘What we are announcing today is probably the limit of what we can achieve in this Parliament, given what needs to be done to implement it,’ he said.
‘But we want to inform the Parliament after this one, so that decisions can be taken about that long-term relationship.’
Kemi Badenoch and Nigel Farage have both condemned the deals struck in principle today.
However, penalty clauses are being included that could leave the UK paying billions of pounds if either party came to power and pulled out.
Mr Farage declared at a press conference in Brussels this evening that he would withdraw from the agreement and refuse to pay.
Chancellor John Healey, deputy PM Louise Haigh, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, Europe minister Hamish Falconer, and Environment Secretary Angela Eagle are among the Cabinet stalwarts at the summit.
Labour chief whip Anneliese Midgley was also on hand for the diplomatic moment.
Downing Street insisted negotiations were complete just after 10am this morning, after claiming last night that they were ‘going down to the wire’.
A spokesman said: ‘The deal is done – negotiations have concluded.
‘Now, both sides will work towards implementation of the youth mobility scheme, the SPS [sanitary and phytosanitary] deal and the emissions trading scheme.
‘Both sides have agreed when these will come into force. And those dates are set out in the joint statement, which will be published in due course.
‘As with all international agreements, there is a legal process in each respective country which will now take place.
‘And talks will continue on some areas – these will be set out in the joint statement later.’
The package includes aligning with EU rules on food to ease border friction – with the UK contributing to the running costs of the system – as well as linking to the bloc’s carbon emissions market.
The joint UK-EU statement also mentions ongoing talks about joining the bloc’s electricity market, but adds: ‘Any such agreement would be linked to a UK financial contribution to reducing economic, social and territorial disparities between regions of the EU.’
Much of the content had been lined up under Keir Starmer, but Mr Burnham appears to have offered deeper compromises than were previously on the table.
The UK had originally insisted that a ‘youth mobility’ scheme should only be open to 50,000 people from the EU every year, but that looks to have doubled.
As the scheme will operate on a rolling three-year basis, it means at least 300,000 people will have the right to come and work in the UK.
Since Brexit, EU students in the UK have been charged higher international fees of between £11,400 and £38,000 a year for undergraduate courses. That is compared to the lower domestic rate for British students of £9,790 a year.
Brussels has been calling for the rates to be slashed to the same as UK students.
And this morning an EU official appeared to connect that issue directly to the fate of the wider package.
‘We have given ourselves a deadline of six months to solve this issue, we have been in talks with the UK,’ they told a briefing for journalists.
Ms von der Leyen was a key figure in the talks as EU commission president
‘I think our position has been clear that this is an issue that needs to be addressed. Since Brexit the level of students from both sides studying on the other side has decreased, notably EU students in the UK.
‘We think this is something that makes our relationship poorer and we want to address this.
‘So we have given us six months to solve this. As for the other agreements we hope they will come into force quickly but we have been negotiating these in parallel and we think that they should also come into force in a balanced way. So this is our expectation and … we think this will be met.’
The official was pressed repeatedly on whether the other elements of the agreement would go ahead without a deal on tuitions fees, and declined to say they would.
According to Politico, the position is being laid out in a statement set to be approved by EU ambassadors.
A draft version of the statement says: ‘The Council agrees that adoption of the Council Decisions on signing of the ETS, SPS and YES agreements will not precede the conclusion of the negotiations on the supplementing Agreement providing for equal treatment on tuition fees.’
The SPS deal is not expected to be implemented until March 2028, well after the six-month deadline for settling the tuition fee spat.
Mr Farage said: ‘Naive Andy Burnham has gone to Brussels and been hit by the stark reality I’ve warned about for decades.
‘Flexibility is a fantasy. They’ve used this moment to strong-arm the British prime minister over tuition fee cuts for hundreds of thousands of EU students, and have absolutely no concern for the impact it will have on Britain.
‘It’s the same old game, and he’s fallen for it out of sheer inexperience.’
The PM met Ms von der Leyen in Brussels this morning, having travelled to the Belgian capital from Berlin last night.
He told EU chiefs: ‘I think we are working together in a world that is changing around us to come back closer and, in doing so, make ourselves stronger, both our economies and our security.
‘It’s a pleasure to be with you today to make this landmark agreement.’
The outcomes of the summit ‘will benefit every single person’ in the UK and EU, he said.
The deal on food imports and exports ‘holds out the real prospect that the cost of the weekly shop will begin to come down’.
The UK’s participation in the Channel action plan would help address the ‘very legitimate concerns’ people have about illegal immigration, he said.
Referring to the agreement on youth mobility he said Brexit in 2016 ‘limited the horizons of our young people in quite a significant way in terms of their opportunities in life’.
Ms von der Leyen told Mr Burnham ‘we are at a turning point’ and ‘we have made a political choice to strengthen our partnership’.
The UK and EU were ‘good old friends that are rejuvenating the friendship’, she said.
Welcoming the youth experience deal she said the young people of the UK and EU would be ‘the best ambassadors for our friendship’.
Earlier, Mr Burnham told business leaders that the Treasury believed the package would add 0.5 percentage points to GDP.
The food and agriculture deal is claimed to add up to £5.1billion a year to the economy, cutting red tape by removing the need for certificates and border checks for products crossing between the UK and EU.
Linking the emissions trading regime, which will protect British exporters from facing a carbon tax when supplying customers in the EU, could add a £3.8billion annual boost, according to officials.
Mr Burnham has said he is still pushing for agreement on a new ‘Channel Action Plan’ to deliver greater co-operation on tackling illegal migration.
Sources indicated it could eventually see the UK sign up to a new EU initiative to send failed asylum seekers to Rwanda – reviving a Tory idea that was scrapped by Labour.
The food and agriculture deal, aimed at ending post-Brexit export checks, would see Britain align with the EU on trade rules on sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) goods, such as food and plants from March 2028.
But the two sides have been haggling over what role Britain would have in setting future SPS laws.
Other areas where there are expected to be commitments following the Brussels talks include economic security covering issues including supply chains and a new digital partnership between the UK and EU.
Mr Farage accused Mr Burnham of ‘betrayal’ and added: ‘I’m afraid that the great Brexit debate has just started again.’
‘We don’t need to be in political union of any kind at all to do business and have good relations with our neighbours,’ he said.
‘That’s the betrayal that Burnham is committing today and he’s trying to do it incrementally but it’s perfectly clear that this very very soon becomes a debate about: do we rejoin or do we stay out?’
Mr Burnham told business leaders in Brussels earlier that the deal can boost the economy and bring down costs for households
He acknowledged that for food exporters a deal on agricultural standards will make things ‘a little bit easier’ but it comes at the cost of giving up control over regulation.
The Reform leader told BBC Radio 4’s Today: ‘The Labour Party was elected, saying they would not rejoin the single market. Well, today we’re rejoining a chunk of it.’
The Conservatives accused the Government of preparing to ‘sell out’ British farmers by becoming a rule taker.
Tory Deputy Leader Alex Burghart said: ‘Rather than fixing the big problems facing the country like the spiralling welfare bill and the need to fund our defence, Andy Burnham is reopening the divisions of the past.
‘Because he is a bad negotiator, British taxpayers will be left paying into the EU, our energy prices will increase, our farmers will be forced to follow EU rules and we will see hundreds of thousands more migrants coming here just when Britain is seeing a lost generation of young people unable to find work.
‘Labour haven’t ruled out asking British taxpayers to subsidise European students’ university fees, despite not being able to find the money to fix plan 2 student loans.
‘Labour is looking backwards at the exact time we need an ambitious government focused on the future.’




