Blue state surtaxes hit high earners hardest at moments of success

There’s a new playbook in blue state taxation, and it’s not being clearly explained to the people paying the bill.

This is called additional tax.

And if you think this is just another tax bracket, you’re already missing the point.

BILL MAHER CALLS BERNIE SANDERS, SAYS HE’S TIRED OF HEARING ABOUT THE RICH PEOPLE NOT PAYING THEIR FAIR SHARE OF TAXES

What is additional tax?

A surtax is a tax added on top of existing income tax, not a replacement for it.

Simply put, here’s how it works: You pay your regular state income tax, and when your income exceeds a certain threshold, the state adds an extra percentage on top of the same income.

Additional taxes are not just about taxing the rich. They are about engineering revenue from high value moments.

It’s the difference between climbing a ladder and having it add another rung above you just when you think you’ve reached the top and achieved success. So why should you be punished for being successful? Anti-capitalist.

Why do blue states use surtaxes?

States use additional taxes for a simple reason: Target revenue without widespread repercussion.

AMERICANS CONTINUE TO VOTE WITH THEIR FEET AS HIGH-TAX CITIES TRY TO RECOVER

Instead of increasing taxes on everyone, these states could:

• Focus on high-income earners, who are often business owners who create jobs.
• They can generate income from one-time unexpected events such as business sales and stock gains.
• Even if you pay seven figures in taxes, they can sell it as political “fairness”.
• And it works because only a small percentage of taxpayers are directly affected, but they receive a disproportionate share of revenue.

How does the surtax actually work in each state?

Let’s examine the five states leading this surtax movement and see what they’re actually doing.

massachusetts

Massachusetts is the clearest example of this.

NEW CHAMBER OF COMMERCE SURVEY SHOWS YOUNG PEOPLE PLANNING TO LEAVE BOSTON BECAUSE OF HIGH RENTS AND ‘SAFETY’

Basic income tax: 5% flat rate. Additional tax: Approximately 4% on income over $1 million.

This means that income above the threshold will be taxed at a total rate of 9%.

If you are selling a business or experiencing a liquidity event, that extra 4% is applied directly to earnings, not to your entire income, but to everything above the line. How nice it is to start a business, employ hundreds of people, and pay even more when you sell it.

CALIFORNIA BILLIONAIRES ESCAPE THE STATE WEALTH TAX IN THE MOST PREDICTABLE OUTCOME EVER

California

California takes a slightly different approach.

Base cap rate: 12.3% Additional tax: 1% on income over $1 million

TAX FIGHT PUT CALIFORNIA INTO CONFLICT AS BILLIONAIRES LEAVE TO RED STATES

This pushes the effective top rate to 13.3%.

This surcharge was originally tied to mental health funding, but make no mistake: This is a permanent tier for high earners.

New Jersey

‘WENT TO FLORIDA AND TEXAS’: NEW BILLBOARDS HIT NY, NJ OVER HIGH SETTLEMENT FLIGHT TO RED STATES

New Jersey operates more like a graduated surtax system.

Income over $1 million is taxed at 10.75%.

This isn’t labeled as an “additional tax,” but it functionally acts as such because your marginal tax rate increases significantly once you exceed the threshold.

FOUR LESSONS WHY THE ‘BOOM BELT’ IS MAKING SO MUCH NOISE WITH MIGRATION

This is essentially a millionaire surcharge added to the rate structure.

new York

New York has one of the most aggressive systems.

NEW YORK’S HOCHUL TOOK ME TO FLORIDA – NOW HE’S BEGGING ME TO RETURN. IT ISN’T HAPPENING

Top state rate: add New York City tax of up to 10.9% on very high incomes; the top earners’ total may exceed 13%.

Although technically structured as a bracket, the “millionaires tax” functions as a surtax because rates rise so quickly at the top.

Hawaii

Hawaii flies under the radar, but it shouldn’t.

THE NEXT BIG TAX THREAT IS COMING FROM YOUR STATE CAPITAL

Maximum rate: around 11%. Recent regulations added higher tiers for top earners.

It’s not always labeled as a surtax, but the effect is the same: a layer of premium tax on higher income levels.

The sinister part they don’t tell you

Here’s what isn’t the subject of political debate:

Additional taxes are not just about income. Instead, they’re about timing.

They hit most in the following situations:

• You are selling a business
• You exercise stock options
• You have a one-time capital gain

BROKEN REGULATIONS: EVEN YOUR TRASH CAN’T Escape CALIFORNIA’S bureaucracy

In other words, they aim not only for stable earnings, but also for moments of success. And if you’re successful, you’ll likely acquire more property and pay more property taxes and excise taxes, if any. You can only keep 50 cents of every dollar you earn.

real world impact

Once you pass this threshold, your marginal tax rate rises rapidly.

In Massachusetts, that extra 4% could mean:

$40,000 for every additional $1 million plus hundreds of thousands, potentially millions, of dollars lost out of business

And when you add federal taxes on top, the total tax amount becomes very real.

bottom line

Additional taxes are not just about taxing the rich. They are about engineering revenue from high value moments.

They are precise. They are being targeted. And they are expanding.

CLICK TO DOWNLOAD FOX NEWS APPLICATION

My advice to all Americans: Be careful so this doesn’t become the federal government’s job in the future.

Because once a state realizes that it can quietly add another layer on top, it is very difficult to remove it.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM TED JENKIN