‘Inconceivable’: apology for body parts secretly kept

Fifty years after burying his brother and best friend, John Santi spent nearly every other week by his grave.
So when he saw his brother’s name in a newspaper and 143 others urging family members to contact the coroner, it was the start of 16 months of hell that culminated in a formal apology from the Tasmanian government.
Tony Santi died in a motorcycle accident in 1976 when he was 19 years old.
13-year-old John recalled his brother’s body being taken to the Royal Hobart Hospital before his family received the body for burial.
But an official investigation in September found the University of Tasmania’s RA Rodda Museum secretly stored 177 human autopsy specimens for educational and research purposes between 1966 and 1991.
Tony was one of them.
The remains were collected without the knowledge or consent of the families or loved ones.
“We buried him 50 years ago, but 50 years later we found out these people had stolen his brain,” John told AAP.
“Every second week I was going to my brother’s grave and then I realized he wasn’t there.”
The Tasmanian government will formally apologize on Tuesday for the past practice of storing body parts after autopsy without the knowledge or consent of family members.
John recalled the confusion between him and his siblings after seeing Tony’s name in the newspaper in 2025.
The coroner told him it was just a small piece of the brain preserved.
“When I met the funeral attendees at the cemetery to rebury the brain piece, they gave it to me in a shoebox,” John said.
“I opened his shoebox and his whole brain was there.
“Having to rebury a loved one twice in 50 years is unthinkable.”
A criminal investigation was launched in 2016 after the museum curator raised concerns that three specimens had been stored without permission from the coroner or the families involved.
Coroner Simon Cooper said in his September report that deceased forensic pathologist Royal Cummings had provided the vast majority of the samples to the museum.
The remains in question were removed from public display in 2018 before the medical examiner spent years reconciling records to determine their origins.
Independent MP Meg Webb said the formal apology was an important step towards responsibility and accountability, but it would not undo the harm done, answer all the unresolved questions or rebuild the trust that was broken.
“Further action may be necessary to ensure that families who have suffered unspeakable treatment of their loved ones are appropriately compensated,” he said.
John hopes for accountability from the relevant departments, justice for those who steal people’s organs, and compensation for the trauma they have suffered.
“It took too long and was, and still is, very traumatic for the families, and I don’t think an apology would make much of a difference to anyone,” he said.
The University of Tasmania had previously apologized and spoken to families.

