Schumer beef industry bill risks raising prices, not lowering them
NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has never worked on a cattle ranch. He never operated a meatpacking plant. And after America sees his backyard grilling demonstration, it’s fair to ask if he knows how to properly grill a cheeseburger.
But as Americans prepare to celebrate the 250th anniversary of our nation’s independence on July 4, in the midst of summer grilling season, Schumer wants Washington to beef up the U.S. beef industry.
What could go wrong?
TRUMP WILL WELCOME FARMERS AND RAMBERS TO DINNER AT THE WHITE HOUSE TO CELEBRATE TRADE AND TAX EARNINGS
Plenty of.
Sen. Chuck Schumer’s grilling skills have been criticized by both the left and the right in this now-deleted X post. He is seen placing American cheese on an uncooked burger. (X)
Schumer’s so-called “Family Grocer and Farmer Relief Act” is classic Washington liberalism: find a real problem, misdiagnose the cause, prescribe a treatment that makes things worse, and call it “relief.” We have seen this in health, energy, housing and education. Politicians create or worsen a crisis, blame it on private enterprise, and then use the pain as an excuse to expand government control.
Beef prices are high. Families feel this every time they go to the market. But this isn’t due to a conspiracy caricatured by meat packers. This is basic economics: strong demand and tight supply.
DESPITE RECORD MEAT PRICES, AMERICANS STILL WANT PROTEIN AS EXPERT REVEALS THE ‘HEALTHIEST BURGER’
As retail beef demand rises sharply from 2019 to 2025, America’s cattle herd has fallen to a 75-year low. According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, total U.S. cattle and calves stand at just 86.2 million head as of January 1, 2026. This is a sharp decline from January 1, 2019, when the inventory was at 94.8 million head, down nearly 9% over seven years. The 2025 calf crop reached a record low of 32.9 million head, setting a new record low for the second year in a row.
This is not price gouging. That is, supply and demand.
Drought has negatively affected major cattle-producing states for years. Farmers faced increasing costs of feed, energy, land, labor and regulation. Inflationary Biden-era policies promoted by Schumer and his allies have made everything more expensive for farmers, processors, and consumers.
Schumer now wants to punish the supply chain on which families depend.
Cattle are not tools. Congress can’t just pass a bill and produce more beef. Chickens can be raised for market within weeks. Beef takes years to raise. The process from a heifer’s birth to the point where her offspring can transition to meat production can take approximately three years. This long cycle depends on weather, feed, financing, land, labor, trade policy and trust that the government will not suddenly change the rules mid-stream.
No Senate press conference can speed up biology.
Schumer’s so-called “Family Grocer and Farmer Relief Act” is classic Washington liberalism: find a real problem, misdiagnose the cause, prescribe a treatment that makes things worse, and call it “relief.”
The facts about meatpacking also shatter Democrats’ price-gouging narrative. In 2025, cattle packer margins showed an average loss of $138 per capita. Tyson Foods reported an operating loss of more than $1 billion on its beef division that year. These are not the number of monopolists pocketing windfall profits. These are the numbers for a capital-intensive industry squeezed by the tightest cattle supply in more than three generations.
But Schumer’s bill ignores all of this. It also ignores the damage done by years of anti-business policies pushed by the same politicians who now act as champions of consumers.
Instead of cutting costs, reducing regulatory hurdles, encouraging investment, expanding processing capacity and keeping trade channels open, Schumer wants Washington to politically restructure the beef industry amid a supply shortage.
This is economic malpractice.
Cattle farmer Brad Randel rounds up some of his black Angus cattle to sell at an auction on September 12, 2022 in McCook, Nebraska. (Ricky Carioti/Washington Post/Getty Images)
Breaking up companies may make good populist rhetoric, but it’s rarely clean, fast or cheap. Forced restructuring in meat processing will mean duplicative infrastructure, higher financing costs, disinvestment, litigation and uncertainty across the supply chain. Likely outcome: Less efficiency, less capacity, more risk and higher prices at the meat aisle.
Wealthy customers who buy quality meat from boutique butchers may not notice this much. Working families who buy burgers, tacos, meatballs, and ground beef for weeknight dinners will do so.
There is a better way. Washington must reduce the cost pressures that make beef more expensive in the first place. Relieve unnecessary regulatory burdens on farmers, ranchers, and processors. Lower energy and transportation costs. Keep import and export markets open during changing supply cycles. Reduce tariff and input cost pressures that make herd rebuilding slower and more expensive.
Most importantly, let the markets work.
And let’s not forget who pushed this plan. Schumer’s allies include political wing Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass. and Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt. It is located; The same crowd that has been demonizing beef for years, lecturing Americans about what they eat, and flirting with Green New Deal ideas that would make food, fuel, and electricity more expensive.
Inflationary Biden-era policies promoted by Schumer and his allies have made everything more expensive for farmers, processors, and consumers.
One day they told us to eat less beef to save the planet. They act surprised that the beef is more expensive the next day.
CLICK FOR OTHER OPINIONS OF FOX NEWS
America’s beef market will recover, but it won’t if Washington turns the supply problem into a government control problem. Herds can be rebuilt. The investment may return. Prices may relax. But this requires stability, lower costs and trust; It’s not about politicians threatening to remake an entire industry for a campaign speech.
CLICK TO DOWNLOAD FOX NEWS APPLICATION
As America celebrates 250 years of independence, we need to remember what made this country prosperous: private enterprise, property rights, limited government, and the free market.
Chuck Schumer might not know how to fry a cheeseburger. But he needs to know enough not to burn the beef industry.
CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM STEVE FORBES
