SNP would set maximum price for essential foods, says Swinney as he fears costs affecting nutrition in Scotland – UK politics live | Politics
Swinney says SNP would set maximum prices for essential food items, using public health powers, on nutrition grounds
Swinney says people are struggling to afford food. That is an “outrage”, he says.
He cannot set prices at the till, he says.
But he says the Scottish government does have powers over public health. He goes on:
It is now impacting on our nation’s nutrition. That is a public health issue and I have public health powers, so I can answer today that, if re-elected, your SNP government will use our public health powers to set a maximum price for essential food items, reducing the price of the weekly shop, putting more money in people’s pockets.
Bread. Milk. Cheese. Eggs. Rice. Chicken. Everyday items that make up a decent diet. Necessities that no one should ever have beyond their means. That’s what you get with a government on Scotland side.
Key events
Swinney says it would be ‘realistic’ for independence referendum to be held in 2028 if SNP wins
Q: On Sunday you said an independence referendum could be held as soon as 2028. Do you think that is realistic?
Swinney replies:
I think it’s very realistic because I’ve set out to people in Scotland the proposition that I put that, if the SNP wins a majority, we should be able to take forward a referendum on independence. And the legislation is legislation with which we are familiar. It can be passed by the Scottish parliament in proper order to enable that decision to be taken at that time.
Q: Looking at the Aldi website, you can already get a loaf of bread for 55p, 15 eggs for £2, a kilo of rise for £1.39. Cheap items are available already. What prices are you thinking of?
Swinney says he is not going to set prices now. There would be a consultation. But he wants to ensure cheap food is available, he says.
Swinney says he is not proposing to put a cap on all prices in supermarkets. He says:
The way this would work is that it would not control all prices in supermarkets. It would place an obligation on supermarkets … to have an essential basket of items that individuals could reliably afford within the supermarket.
So a loaf of bread at an affordable level. But there could be other loaves of bread that were more expensive than that loaf of bread.
Fundamentally, it is about using our powers to protect the pursuit of a nutritious diet by members of the public, and a legitimate exercise of our powers.
Q: Have you consulted on your plan for maximum prices for essential foods? Do you anticipate a legal challenge?
Swinney says he believes he does have the power to do this. He would consult on implementation, he says.
Q: The manifesto says you want to simplify the tax system, but not increase rates or bands. Does that mean cutting some of the lower bands?
Here is the passage in the manifesto.
Swinney just repeats the pledge about not repeating the number of bands or rates.
Swinney is now taking questions.
Q: You say you will cut the number of public bodies. How many people would lose their jobs?
Swinney says there will be job losses, but frontline staff will be protected.
He does not give a number.
Swinney says the SNP will pursue policies to promote growth.
I want to use every single lever available to the Scottish government to boost economic growth, support innovation and attract investment.
He also recalls marching against the Iraq war in Glasgow 20 years ago, and says an SNP government stands for international justice.
He concludes:
On 7 May vote SNP for a government on Scotland’s side. Vote SNP for the trusted, experienced leadership that I offer as first minister. Vote SNP for bold action on the cost of living and on our health service. Vote SNP for hope over despair and vote SNP to give Scotland a fresh start with independence.
Swinney says SNP would set maximum prices for essential food items, using public health powers, on nutrition grounds
Swinney says people are struggling to afford food. That is an “outrage”, he says.
He cannot set prices at the till, he says.
But he says the Scottish government does have powers over public health. He goes on:
It is now impacting on our nation’s nutrition. That is a public health issue and I have public health powers, so I can answer today that, if re-elected, your SNP government will use our public health powers to set a maximum price for essential food items, reducing the price of the weekly shop, putting more money in people’s pockets.
Bread. Milk. Cheese. Eggs. Rice. Chicken. Everyday items that make up a decent diet. Necessities that no one should ever have beyond their means. That’s what you get with a government on Scotland side.
Swinney says SNP will cap all bus fares in Scotland at £2 if it wins
Swinney sums up some manifesto proposals already announced.
A re-elected SNP government will, for people trying to buy their first home, help you onto the property ladder with £10,000 towards your deposit.
For private renters, the right of first refusal to buy your home if it goes on sale for parents will intensify.
Scotland’s childcare revolution. Extending support over the next parliament to every child in the country from nine months old to the end of primary school all year round, and we will build on the success of the baby box with a new welcome to school bag.
Swinney says the Scottish government has already done a lot of concessionary travel, but it wants to go further, he says.
People need to be able to afford to get to the work, to go out and to see friends, to get out and about.
The cost of travelling from Hamilton, for example, to get here today by bus would cost more than £7. From Paisley it would cost £6. From Dumbarton it would cost £9.30. These costs are too high.
So I can announce today that if re-elected, an SNP government will cap bus fares at £2 in every part of Scotland.
Swinney says this is a manifesto for the whole of Scotland.
He confirms that the SNP would argue for the Scottish power to have more control over energy policy (still largely reserved to Westminter). He says:
The problem is not that we do not have the energy. The problem is that Westminster has the power. This election is our opportunity to take those powers and put them into Scotland’s hands.
Swinney confirms that he views a vote for the SNP as a vote to hold a referendum on independence.
That would be “a referendum that will allow Scotland to reclaim our place at the heart of Europe, and a referendum that I intend to win”, he says.
Swinney highlights his record as first minister, and says he’s ‘only just getting started’
John Swinney, the SNP leader and first minister, is speaking now.
He starts saying:
In the two years since becoming first minister, I’ve dedicated every single day to improving the lives of the people of Scotland.
When I took office, I promised I would deliver for Scotland falling waiting times, more operations, GP walk-in clinics, frozen rail fares, peak rail fares abolished, child poverty down and winter fuel payments restored. Friends, I keep my promises. That is my record. It’s a record I’m proud to take to the people of Scotland.
He goes on:
But make no mistake about it, I am only just getting started.
This is a reference to how Swinney was originally seen as a stopgap FM when he was chosen after the surprise resignation of Humza Yousaf.
SNP launches election manifesto
The SNP is launching its manifesto.
Jenny Gilruth, the Scottish government’s education secretary, is doing the warm-up speech for John Swinney. She says the party is fighting for a fifth successive election win.
She says Swinney stands “head and shoulders” above other candidates for first minnister.
Hospital waiting lists in England fall for fourth month in row, reaching lowest level since February 2023
The waiting list for routine hospital treatment in England has fallen for the fourth month in a row, the Press Association reports. PA says:
An estimated 7.22 million treatments were waiting to be carried out at the end of February, relating to 6.11 million patients.
This is down from 7.25 million treatments and 6.13 million patients at the end of January.
The number of treatments waiting to be carried out is at its lowest level since February 2023, when it stood at 7.22 million.
The list hit a record high in September 2023, with 7.77 million treatments and 6.50 million patients.
Government extends scheme to help firms in energy-intensive industries with fuel bills
Peter Kyle, the business secretary, was giving interviews this morning to promote a government announcement that will help companies in energy-intensive industries with fuel bills.
As the Department for Business and Trade says in a news release, the existing scheme – the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme, or BICS – is being expanded. It says:
Automotive and aerospace, steel, and pharmaceuticals are among the sectors where eligible businesses are to benefit from a one-off additional payment in 2027. This will cover the support firms would have received if BICS had been in place from April 2026.
Eligibility has also been expanded by 40%, from 7,000 to over 10,000 businesses. This targets support at energy-intensive firms on the number one issue they face – high electricity costs.
From April 2027, eligible firms will see electricity bills cut by up to 25 percent. Households will see no increase in their bills as a result.
BICS will exempt eligible businesses from the indirect costs of three electricity schemes: the Renewables Obligation, Feed-in Tariffs, and the Capacity Market. This is worth around £35–£40 per MWh.
It is expected to be worth up to £600m per year from April 2027. Households and other businesses not benefiting will see no increase in their energy bills.
The government says sectors that could benefit “include automotive and aerospace, steel producers, metal fabricators, pharmaceutical and medical supplies companies, recycling businesses, plastic producers, nuclear fuel processors, and cooling and ventilation equipment manufacturers.”
Heather Stewart and Richard Partington have more on this announcement here.
Reform UK says it would tighten law to make prosecuting lawyers who help with bogus asylum claims easier
Reform UK has said that it would tighten the law to make it easier to prosecute lawyers and advisers who help people make bogus asylum claims.
Zia Yusuf, the party’s home affairs spokesperson, announced the proposals in response to a major BBC investigation illustrating the extent of fraud in the asylum advice industry.
A report yesterday, by Billy Kenber and Phil Kemp, said “migrants are falsely claiming to be victims of domestic abuse in order to stay in the country”. Today they have followed it up with a second report about how “migrants are falsely claiming to be victims of domestic abuse in order to stay in the country”.
In a response to the initial investigation, Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, said:
Anyone abusing protections for people fleeing persecution over gender or sexual orientation is beyond contempt.
Let me be clear: try to defraud the British people to enter or remain in the UK and your asylum claim will be refused, your support cut off, and you will find yourself on a one-way flight out of Britain.
Sham lawyers facilitating this abuse will face the full force of the law.
Today Reform UK went further. Yusuf said:
A Reform UK government will put a stop to the legal-industrial complex exploiting the generosity of the British taxpayer. We will criminally prosecute unscrupulous immigration lawyers by creating a new strict liability offence. We will also end legal aid for illegal arrivals and visa overstayers. Those who break into our country will no longer get taxpayer funds to fight their removal.
Reform will ensure our borders are secured, illegal migrants deported and British taxpayers are no longer defrauded in this manner.
Explaining the proposed change, Reform UK said:
A Reform government will make facilitating a false asylum claim a ‘strict liability’ criminal offence. There will be no requirement to prove intent in prosecutions, and this serious crime will be punishable by up to 2 years in jail. Lawyers defrauding the British people in this way will not be tolerated. Similar duties already apply to law firms and lawyers to prevent bribery and tax evasion and it’s reasonable to also apply this to immigration law firms.
Swinney says it will legislate for smartphone ban in Scottish schools if it wins Holyrood election
The SNP is to bring in a national ban on smartphones in classes if it wins May’s Holyrood election, John Swinney has pledged. As the Press Association reports, the first minister and SNP leader insisted the devices were “a distraction from learning” pledging legislation after the election to ban them across Scotland. PA says:
Currently head teachers have the power to ban smartphones in their schools, with a number of councils in Scotland having acted.
However Swinney said that the SNP will now seek to “ensure a full national ban in Scotland’s classrooms”.
He told the Daily Record newspaper: “We have already taken action to empower headteachers to act but if re-elected we will legislate to deliver a full ban across Scotland.
“The SNP is on the side of schools and we will take every step necessary to ensure teaching in our classrooms is done without distraction.
“We have record levels of literacy and numeracy in our schools and this national ban will support pupils and teachers to build on that progress.”
UK economy showed surprise 0.5% growth before Iran war
UK GDP expanded by a stronger than expected 0.5% in February, official figures show, suggesting the economy was gaining momentum before the onset of war in the Middle East dashed hopes of recovery, Heather Stewart reports.
Contingency plans in place for possible food shortages if Iran war continues, Peter Kyle confirms
Good morning. ‘We don’t comment on leaks,’ is the usual government response to an unsanctioned lobby scoop. But this morning Peter Kyle, the business secretary, took a different response. Asked about a Times splash saying the government is making plans to deal with possible food shortages in the summer, caused by the Iran war, he told Sky News:
It is difficult for me, because, of course, these leaks are very unhelpful. But when people do read it, they need to be reassured that we are doing this kind of planning, and we are doing this kind of scenario planning.
Kyle contrasted his stance with Boris Johnson’s conduct in the early days of Covid, when the Tory PM “missed five Cobra meetings in the lead-up to it”.
The Times story, by Aubrey Allegretti, is not saying that the country is going to run out of food. But it does say that serious contingency planning is taking place, with an assumption that under a “reasonable worst-case scenario”, supermarkets might start running out of some items. Allegretti says:
Britain could face shortages of chicken, pork and other supermarket goods this summer if the war in Iran continues, a secret government analysis has found.
Officials have drawn up contingency plans for a “reasonable worst-case scenario” amid fears that the closure of the Strait of Hormuz will lead to shortages of carbon dioxide (CO2) which is critical to the food industry …
Farming and hospitality would likely be hit earliest and hardest, given CO2 is used to help increase the shelf life of food such as salad, packaged meats and baked goods.
CO2 is used in the process of slaughtering nearly all pigs and more than two thirds of chickens and the sector is not thought to have much by way of surplus supplies. While the government does have stockpiles, this was said to not be a long-term solution …
While there are not expected to be critical food supply shortages, officials expect there could be a lack of product variety in shops.
The “reasonable worst-case scenario” assumes that by June the strait of Hormuz is still closed, and there is no permanent peace deal. According to Allegretti’s story, officials are working on the basis that, in these circumstances, supplies of CO2 could fall to just 18 per cent of present levels. This could have consequences for healthcare and the energy sector, as well as the food industry. Allegretti says one plan involves possible emergency legislation being passed to require factorsies to maximise CO2 production.
In interviews this morning, Kyle did not dispute the story; instead he presented it as evidence of the government taking emergency planning seriously.
He told Times Radio:
I can tell you, because I’m in these meetings, the prime minister has been there since the very start, and he is going through personally and driving deep dives into lots of areas of resilience throughout our economy.
He said that at the start of the conflict he reversed the mothballing of the Ensus bio-ethanol plant in Teesside to secure supplies of carbon dioxide.
People should be reassured that we are doing this kind of action behind the scenes to keep resilience in our economy, so that when the full extent of what may or may not emerge, because this situation is still unfolding in the Middle East, you have a government that is acting with creativity and boldness.
Kyle told Sky News that supplies of CO2 were “not a concern” now.
He went on:
If any of these things change, I will be up front with the public about it in advance so that we can prepare. But right now, people should go on as they are, enjoying beer, enjoying their meats, enjoying all the salads.
But also there are critical uses for CO2 – MRI scanning, for example, water purification; it’s involved in our nuclear industry, our civil nuclear power industry, some defensive uses for it as well.
There’s lots of needs for CO2, so these are the reasons why I took it so seriously way back to six months ago, not just in the last few weeks.
Here is the agenda for the day.
Morning: Keir Starmer meets executives from tech companies including TikTok, X and Meta in Downing Street to discuss restricting social media for teenagers. Last night, for the second time, MPs rejected a proposal to ban under-16s from using social media.
9.30am: NHS England publishes its monthly performance figures.
10am: John Swinney, the SNP leader and Scotland’s first minister, launches the SNP manifesto for the Holyrood election.
Morning: Nigel Farage, the Reform UK leader, does a walkabout in South Wales Valleys town with the party’s Welsh leader, Dan Thomas.
11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.
Noon: The Covid inquiry publishes its report on vaccines and therapeutics.
Afternoon (UK time): Rachel Reeves attends IMF meeting in Washington. She is also doing a huddle with reporters.
4pm: Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, and Russell Findlay, the party’s leader in Scotland, attend a rally in Edinburgh.
I am afraid we are not able to open comments on the blog today because we do not moderators available; I am sorry about that.
If you want to to contact me, you can use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn.bsky.social. The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary.
I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.
