Germany are OUT of the World Cup! Kai Havertz and Nick Woltemade miss crucial penalties as Paraguay produce shock of the tournament to reach last-16

For those hoping to see Jurgen Klopp on the touchline in the near future, Germany may have done at least one favor this World Cup. In all other respects, they failed miserably.
When their demise was sealed by Paraguay’s Jose Canale strike at the end of the frantic penalty shoot-out, the only mystery was how long Julian Nagelsmann could survive in his post. Will it take hours or days? Will Klopp be next?
He never hid his interest, and they never had much need. Because it was evil. It was a bleak situation. This was a powerful nation taking on a minnow and beating them in their own penalty game.
So, let’s talk a little about how Germany lost the penalty shootout for the first time in a World Cup.
The previous 120 minutes had passed with a score of 1-1. But the finale was ridiculous. Orlando Gill’s saves Kai Havertz and Nick Woltemade seemingly turned it into a parade, but then Antonio Sanabria and Fabián Balbuena did our best. Wimbledon two weeks, term match point.
When Jonathan Tah later flared, Canele had another chance for Paraguay to seal it. And this time they did just that, storming into the net and sparking the wildest celebrations of the tournament so far. Legendary.
And with that, they, not Germany, will advance to the last 16, facing the winner of France and Sweden.
Your browser does not support iframes.
Kai Havertz (left) and Nick Woltemade (right) missed the decisive penalties as Germany lost
Arsenal star Havertz was first in the penalty shoot-out in Boston, but his penalty was saved
Gustavo Gomez celebrates Jose Canale taking Paraguay’s place in the last 16
The Story of the Oppressed
These tournaments rise and fall on the contributions of the underdogs, and few have looked as toothless as Gustavo Alfaro’s group, which sit outside FIFA’s top 30 and began their campaign with a defeat by the United States.
They escaped group D on that surface outside the blocks, in one of those lucky loser spots, but here they were expected to be crushed.
Having the tricks of Miguel Almiron and the speed of Enciso was just a counterbalance to the four-time champions. How wrong we were.
INVESTIGATION
Naturally, the investigation into Germany’s failure will be brutal. Nagelsmann was under fire for the group stage defeat against Ecuador and tried to brush it off. According to what he said before the match: ‘If you win, everything is perfect, if you lose, everything is terrible.’
This was his critique of snapshot, unnuanced judgments, but there was no subtlety to this loss. No reduction. Germany was terrible. They had all the ball and no clue. They were a team that couldn’t attack and were incompetent when they had to defend, and as a result they fell into a team that spent 75 percent of the game chasing.
The list of those who intervened to share in Nagelsmann’s misery will not be short, which was one of the obstacles to his reign even before this defeat.
Of course, there is pressure on all so-called giants, but not every manager has to contend with such vaunted voices of the expert class. When Klopp did not contribute, key elements of the 2014 World Cup-winning class filled the void; both Toni Kroos and Philipp Lahm said their remarks.
According to Nagelsmann, this is not an easy environment to work in, and the situation is made even more difficult by a strange fact; Criticisms are often appropriate. If we are to give the manager credit for anything, it is that he is not completely blind to shortcomings, as evidenced by his decision to send Jamal Musiala on for Stuttgart striker Deniz Undav.
This carried serious weight as a blood sacrifice – Musiala had his finger on the pulse of Germany’s attacking line at Euro 2024 – but the change did nothing against Paraguay. Undav was substituted in the 63rd minute after showing little else.
Julian Nagelsmann will be under huge pressure to keep his job amid support for Jurgen Klopp
This was a terrible showing by Germany, considering how much of the property they owned here.
Nagelsmann’s critics had also demanded other changes before the match, but these were ignored. Instead, Manuel Neuer stood his ground in the face of recent criticism, as did Florian Wirtz, and Nagelsmann insisted on right-back Joshua Kimmich despite Bayern Munich and the German public seeing him as a midfielder.
Unfortunately, there is a fine line between courage and stubbornness, and this was a difficult time for Nagelsmann’s supporters.
CREATIVE DEFICITS AND LAZY RUNNERS
The first half was a prime example of Germany’s problems; They had better than 80 percent possession and lacked the intelligence to exploit it.
This meant there were no meaningful shots, no clever moves and no idea how to shift gears when it became clear that Paraguay were content to sit deep and punch on the counter. In fact, Wirtz on the left of the 4-4-2 was a passenger, as he had been for most of the tournament, and Undav was isolated. He blamed his seven touches in the first 45 minutes on both Wirtz and Leroy Sane on the opposite wing.
The biggest concern at this point in the match was work tempo and desire. Kimmich had flagged this as a problem following the defeat against Ecuador, and similar thoughts were provoked by Paraguay’s 1-0 goal here.
This was evident in the first phase of the attack, when Juan Jose Caceres was doing his best to win the loose ball, and this was reinforced by the ease with which Enciso met Matias Galarza’s cross. Antonio Rudiger and Jonathan Tah had their eyes on Enciso entering the field and doing nothing. Terrible. We must add to Neuer’s critics that there is nothing he can do about this.
LITTLE DEMONS AND BIG QUESTIONS
Nagelsmann’s response to the goal was to bring on Leon Goretzka just before half-time, but the sharper impact came from the urgency of Germany’s play. Paraguay continued to sit back and that helped, but the Germans were obviously looking to the wings. Suddenly Wirtz and Leroy Sane were options to step in.
They equalized with an attacker from Wirtz as Kai Havertz powered a header. A great goal and a huge relief. Also a question: Why did it take so long to find a solution?
Chasing the win, Nagelsmann connected Undav to Musiala but Musiala only made a minor dent in the play. His form here was truly like a puzzle.
The same was said about Wirtz before kick-off, but at least he showed up in the second half and finally brought out the little devil that lives inside him.
Liverpool fans may have seen little evidence of this, but at best he can pose a threat in slower games. We saw more in the second half, including Havertz’s second superb cross, this time going down the drain with a header.
Paraguay were disciplined, took chances at times, but that’s exactly what the World Cup needs
However, there was no improvement within 90 minutes. There is no light in the darkness. This meant extra time in which Woltemade’s appeal for a penalty failed after an apparent handball from Gustavo Gomez, with Tah heading in at the back post following Nathaniel Brown’s corner.
VAR’s view that Waldemar Anton had fouled the goalkeeper was confirmed and penalties soon became inevitable.
KLOPP FACTOR
All of the above happened in front of Klopp, who hovered over this doomed campaign like a hero in absentia. The calls for him to come and right this German ship will be deafening.




