The study decision that upended the life of a rising Waratahs star
Updated ,first published
Rising Waratahs star Henry O’Donnell’s innocuous decision to take medication to help him focus on university studies cost him 18 months of his rugby career.
Two days before facing the Queensland Reds in Sydney last May, O’Donnell sat down to complete a batch of university assignments for his business degree.
O’Donnell had always strongly suspected that he had ADHD, but was never diagnosed. He sometimes took his brother’s medication to help him focus on his academic studies. The NSW player realized he could eliminate the drug from the competition.
O’Donnell’s mistake was that the drug was still in his system when he played the Reds two days later on Friday, May 9.
“I was tested many times. I didn’t have a second thought about it during the test, (but) three weeks later I was informed that I had failed the doping control test.”
Despite the result, O’Donnell was still able to train and play rugby, including against the British and Irish Lions last July, while seeking an official diagnostic and therapeutic use exemption for ADHD.
A psychiatrist and psychologist later concluded that O’Donnell had suffered from ADHD since childhood. O’Donnell was granted an exemption by the Australian Sports Medicine Medical Advisory Committee, but was told it would not apply retroactively to cover his positive test.
As a result, Sports Integrity Australia banned O’Donnell for 18 months. Following a lengthy SIA process, Rugby Australia and the NSW Waratahs released a statement announcing the sanction on Saturday, saying they had tested positive for D-amphetamine and Ritalinic Acid, two banned substances associated with ADHD medications, without exemption.
“I got a call (from Sports Integrity Australia) at 5pm and they said: ‘We’ll let Rugby Australia know in 15 minutes’. And I said ‘can you wait?’ I said. ‘I need to call (Waratahs coach) Dan (McKellar) because I want to tell him’. I think Dan really appreciates that kind of open honesty, and then I backed off.
There were many difficulties for O’Donnell after this meeting. He was unable to visit the Waratahs for training or to visit socially. The team environment had brought him much happiness since school, but he had to train alone in his garage.
The hardest part was not being able to tell anyone what happened while the long SIA process was going on. O’Donnell explained that he had made a mistake, but he also knew he wasn’t cheating.
Most of his friends and teammates had no idea what had happened to him.
“I was starting to hear some pretty mundane rumors. A few of my really close friends knew, but overall my teammates knew absolutely nothing,” O’Donnell said.
“At first it was personal reasons, then I heard about the police, then I heard about doping, I heard everything.
“I was advised not to talk about it and I think that was probably the hardest thing, given the whole situation.
“And to be honest, my friends weren’t pushy at all. I wasn’t interrogated by any of the boys… but I didn’t want to kill my social life either, so I said to a few close friends: ‘look, I won’t say what it is but don’t ask me any questions but I’m still willing to hang out’.”
In March, O’Donnell received the official letter of charge from Rugby Australia and Sports Integrity Australia, formalizing his 18-month ban. Rugby Australia and NSW Rugby said in a statement that “the SIA found that the infringement was not intentional and occurred in a context unrelated to sporting performance.”
“I think the biggest thing for me from that letter was: Yes, I made a mistake and I will be punished heavily for it,” O’Donnell said.
“But more importantly to me, they acknowledge that this was unintentional and was taken in a context unrelated to sports, which justifies me in cheating, which is something I would never have considered doing.”
Some professional athletes hate the structured nature of their jobs. There is a detailed plan for each hour of the day, such as what to eat, what to wear, and what activity to do. O’Donnell loves it. Starting in September, O’Donnell had to readjust to lonely hours by carefully writing down his workouts on the garage mirror.
“The first few weeks were probably a shock. I really didn’t know what to do with myself. I don’t think I’ve ever been this upset in front of my family,” O’Donnell said.
“I had to figure out how to keep myself busy, I worked hard, I’m probably not the most talented and I think a lot of coaches and players know that I’m very competitive and I push quite hard to get the best out of myself.
“I felt like every day I realized how good our business was, and I think that’s one of the things I took away from this.”
“I mean, I have so much perspective coming out of that about how good our job is every day, how much I really love the sport, I love the kids, I love the Waratahs, how much I love the coaching staff.
“You run the risk of using a cliché, but you don’t know how much you love it until it’s taken away from you.”
As part of his sentence, O’Donnell will not be able to play any sports in any competition, whether it be tennis or golf. He runs at a local park and continues to push himself in the garage.
O’Donnell is also working as a project manager under former Waratahs and Ireland international Matt Mostyn before returning to the Waratahs’ pre-season training in November. Many players fear this date; O’Donnell is counting down to it.
O’Donnell wants to share his story to make sure his teammates don’t have to go through what he went through.
“I understand the system pretty well now. Unfortunately, most athletes treat it like a box-ticking exercise. It’s much more than that. Athletes need to understand the rules. They’re what keeps our sport fair and I agree with that.”
“I have no animosity whatsoever. It would be easy to swing by and say what happened (to me) was bullshit, but I accept it (the punishment) and I don’t want anyone to go through what I went through.”
O’Donnell will be able to return to play for the Waratahs from January 1.
“Henry made an error of judgment and paid dearly for that misstep,” said BJ Mather, Waratah’s Director of High Performance.
“The club has supported Henry throughout the process and we look forward to his return.”
