Trump’s defense of firing BLS chief relies on twisted timeline

President Donald Trump tried to justify the firing of the former Working Statistics Bureau, Erika Mcentarfer, the former Labor Statistics Bureau, claiming that the gold standard employment reports of the agency were “fraudulent” politically.
Even Trump did not provide any evidence to support his claim that lifting will weaken his confidence in the data used to measure the health of the economy and make major policy decisions.
And experts Even if a BLS commissioner wants to manipulate monthly job report data, it will be impossible to consider how the data is collected, analyzed and explained to the public.
However, Trump has repeatedly released “fake” powerful -looking number of jobs in the last year of Biden administration, but just after the 2024 Presidential elections, he has sharply reviewed them.
“Only a few days ago [Nov. 5 presidential] The election revealed the numbers as if the country was burning. “
“And then they made a revision about two weeks later, and the revision fell almost 900,000 work.”
When a host pushed it back, Trump doubled and claimed that “the numbers were fraudulent”.

“These extraordinary numbers have announced a lot of these extraordinary numbers two days before the election and before that, and after that, they always heard a lot … But after winning the election, in other words, they announced a downward number to return to reality.” He said.
However, Trump’s statement on how the job report was published in 2024 is wrong. And it weakens the real timeline claims.
August 2024: Big down revision
BLS’s regular job reports routinely contain revisions in the number of the previous month, because the US drips more data that draws a clearer picture of employment.
It is true that BLS has published a major revision for last year’s work: the agency announced that the US economy has added 818,000 less jobs than reported for the year ending in March 2024.
However, as Trump suggested on Tuesday, this revision did not come after the election. On the contrary, in August 2024-more than two months before the selection and after that, the President was published Kamala Harris took the reins as a democratic candidate.
Trump jumped into the figure then. “New data from the Bureau of Statistics of the Working Statistics show that the administration has completed extra 818,000 work that does not exist and never does.” Real social.
The number came in front of BLS Annual comparison revisionWhen the employment forecasts derived from the surveys are calibrated against state unemployment insurance tax records.
The last comparison, which was published in February months after the election, fell to 598,000, which was lower than the pre -figure from August.
October 2024: Recruitment slows down significantly
Trump is also wrong to claim that Bls has published “extraordinary numbers” just before the 2024 elections.
In fact, the last job report before the election is a A sharp slowdown in planting recruitment after an increase in the previous month.
Less than a week before the election day, the November 1 report showed that only 12,000 workers were added to non -agricultural payrolls in October in October.
At that time, the smallest monthly business gain in about four years, and the experts have already fallen far below the low expectations of the experts.
As soon as the November 1 report was published, Trump, who used the data to suppress Harris, was immediately armed for political purposes.
“Today’s job report is a great embarrassment for our nation. Kamala has lied about the painful business growth that has never been real for years.” Real social November 1 “America is a nation in the fall because the sleepy Joe and Lyin ‘Kamala did not do their work.”
BLS would then review that weak jobs were understood up – but not until Trump wins the election.
Moreover, it is understood that the sharp decrease in the first report of October is now directed by various factors other than anyone’s control.
Great labor strikes at Boeing and the US ports had a short -term impact on removing thousands of workers from payrolls in October.
Hurricanes in the Southeast also closed the roads and enterprises, influenced the first report and made it difficult to collect the right data.

The White House did not respond to CNBC’s request for comment or Trump’s words more.
A Ministry of Labor official, in the comments provided by the White House, criticized Mcentarfer’s leadership, said he expects a long time to inform the department about data collection difficulties in BLS.
However, these are not the criticisms of Trump.
Instead, Trump announced his accusation in Mcentarfer’s social media mission, who accused him of imitating the number of jobs before he chose to increase and increase Kamala’s chance of victory. “
CNBC reached Mcentarfer for a comment.
“I directed my team to expel my team immediately.” “Important numbers like this should be fair and true, they cannot be manipulated for political purposes.”
The shipment arrived hours after the first job report for July showed a weaker growth than expected.
In this report, BLS published two revisions in the first reports from the previous months. Both of them sharply revised their number of jobs down and did a total of 258,000 jobs except for the gang of the year.
Lower revisions and expectations for July created a sharp decline in financial markets. Until Friday Dow Jones Industrial Average More than 500 points fell.
The White House defended Trump’s decision, and in the National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett NBC News, the business revisions to support the President’s claims were “difficult evidence”, he said.
Trump said Mcentarfer has planned to announce his successor in the coming days.




