Asylum seekers face deportation over failure to pay new fees — before being notified

WASHINGTON— Late last month, an immigrant seeking asylum in the United States encountered posts on social media urging him to pay the new fee the Trump administration implemented before October 1 or risk having his case rejected.
Paula, a 40-year-old Mexican Los Angeles-area immigrant whose full name The Times is withholding for fear of retribution, applied for asylum in 2021 and her case is currently under appeal.
But when Paula tried to pay the $100 annual fee, she couldn’t find an option on the immigration court website that accepted fees for pending asylum cases. Fearing deportation and with only five hours until the deadline, he chose the closest amount he could find, $110 for an appeal filed before July 7.
He knew this was probably wrong. Still, he thought it was better to pay for something than to do nothing, as a sign of his good faith. Paula, who repaired bags in a warehouse, paid the fee with a credit card because she could not find the money in such a short time.
“I hope this money doesn’t go to waste,” he said.
This remains unclear due to confusion and misinformation surrounding the introduction of a number of new fees or fee increases for various immigration services. The fees are part of the comprehensive budget bill President Trump signed in July.
Paula was one of thousands of asylum seekers across the country who panicked after seeing messages on social media urging them to pay the new fee before the start of the new financial year on 1 October.
But immigration lawyers say the government’s messaging on fees is sometimes chaotic and contradictory. While some of the refugees received notice of the fees, others did not. Misinformation has also increased as immigrants try to figure out if and how to pay.
Advocates worry that this confusion will lead immigration officials to deny more asylum claims, which could make applicants deportable.
Fees vary. For those seeking asylumThere is a $100 fee for new applications and a $100 annual fee for pending applications. The initial work permit fee is $550, and the work permit renewal fee can go up to $795.
Amy Grenier, deputy director of government relations for the American Immigration Lawyers Assn., said not having a clear way to pay the fee may seem like a small government misstep, but the legal ramifications are significant.
For new asylum applications, he said, some immigration judges have set the payment deadline as Sept. 30, even though the Executive Office for Immigration Review only updates its payment portal in the last week of September.
“The lack of consistent guidance and structure for fee payment has further compounded the inefficiency of our immigration courts,” Grenier said. “There are very real consequences for asylum seekers of being caught up in this completely unnecessary bureaucratic mess.”
Two agencies collect asylum fees: the Department of Homeland Security’s U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and the Department of Justice’s Executive Office of Immigration Review (EOIR), which operates immigration courts.
Both agencies initially issued different instructions regarding fees, and only USCIS provided a means for payment.
The Homeland Security and Justice departments did not respond to a request for comment. The White House deferred to USCIS.
USCIS spokesman Matthew J. Tragesser said the asylum fee was imposed in accordance with the law.
“The real losers in this are unscrupulous and incompetent immigration lawyers who exploit their clients and bog down the system with baseless asylum claims,” he said.
The Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project (ASAP), a national membership organization, sued the Trump administration earlier this month after thousands of members shared confusion over the new fees, arguing that relevant federal agencies “threatened to deprive asylum seekers of full and fair consideration of their claims.”
The organization also argued that the fees should not apply to people whose cases were pending before Trump signed his budget package into law.
In the application filed in the US district court on MondayJustice Department lawyers defended the fees, saying, “Congress has made clear that these new asylum fees are long overdue and necessary to cover the rising costs of adjudicating millions of pending asylum applications.”
Some of the confusion stemmed from conflicting information.
USCIS’ July 22 announcement Federal Register Both immigrants and lawyers were confused by the reference to September 30. Anyone who applied for asylum as of October 1, 2024 and whose application was still pending as of September 30 was ordered to pay a fee. Some thought this notification meant that the deadline for payment of the annual asylum fee was September 30.
USCIS clarifies this month on its website He said he would “issue personal notices” warning asylum seekers about when their annual fee will be paid, how it will be paid and the consequences of not doing so.
The agency created a payment portal and began sending notices to recipients on October 1 instructing them to pay within 30 days.
But many asylum seekers are still waiting to be notified by USCIS, according to the advocacy organization ASAP. While some received text messages or physical mail telling them to check their USCIS accounts, others began checking their accounts every day.
Meanwhile, the Executive Office of Immigration Review (EOIR) has not added a mechanism to pay the $100 fee for pending asylum cases (the fee Paula had hoped to pay). until Thursday.
“Disturbingly, ASAP has received reports that some immigration judges at EOIR are requiring applicants to pay the annual asylum fee and, in at least one case, denying asylum and ordering the deportation of an asylum seeker who has not paid the annual asylum fee even though the agency does not offer any way to pay the fee,” ASAP’s attorneys wrote in the Oct. 3 complaint.
A San Diego immigration attorney, who asked to remain anonymous for fear of retaliation, said an immigration judge denied his client’s asylum petition because his client had not paid the new fee, even though he had no way of paying it.
“Despite this mandatory requirement, the defendants have to date failed to provide documentation of payment of the annual asylum fee,” the judge issued an order shared with The Times.
The lawyer called the decision a violation of due process. He said he now plans to appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals, but another wage increase under Trump’s spending package increased that cost from $110 to $1,010. He is handling the case pro bono.
Justice Department lawyers said Monday that EOIR has eliminated the initial discrepancy by revising its position to reflect USCIS’s and will soon send formal notices to applicants, giving them 30 days to make payments.
“There was no unreasonable delay here in enforcing the EOIR,” the filing said. “…The record demonstrates that several steps, including coordination with USCIS, were necessary to complete the EOIR process. Regardless, Plaintiff’s request is now moot.”
Immigrants like ASAP member Paula have received some reassurance recently. Inside court statementFor anyone who makes advance or advance payments for annual asylum fees, “those payments will be applied, as appropriate, to the fees owed by the alien,” EOIR Director Daren Margolin wrote.




