Scott Pendlebury’s games record, North Melbourne’s miracle comeback and the state of the ladder
A remarkable tour
Remarkably, Carlton won their second game in a row. Less conspicuously, Essendon did not. They lost again. They won one match in 12 months.
Remarkably, GWS edged Brisbane by 13 goals. Less notably, Geelong won again at home, beating two teams currently ranked above them in the standings and last year’s premiers.
Remarkably, North Melbourne pulled off their second-greatest comeback in football by beating Gold Coast. Less notable is that the Suns lost another game after playing in Darwin.
Remarkably, Richmond won another game. Less notably, they did this against Essendon, who lost four players to injury.
A remarkable 90,000 people went to the MCG to watch a non-Victorian team in the bottom four play a team outside the top 10. Less remarkable was the way Collingwood played.
Most notably, Scott Pendlebury broke the games record.
For all the remarkable things that happen in a football weekend, Scott Pendlebury’s match record remains the most extraordinary in the history of football. However, in the context of the season, this was less significant than the injury suffered by Jamie Elliott in the same game. For a team that held on to 10 points and could not score a goal, it was devastating to lose former captain Elliott, who won the game for his team with the goals he scored within minutes in the third quarter.
Pendlespalooza overshadowed much of what happened in football this weekend. Most importantly (until GWS upset Brisbane) Carlton, who had managed one win in nine tries before sacking Michael Voss, have now won two games in a row. In both matches they looked much better not only than their opponents but also than themselves two weeks ago.
Carlton were criticized for the timing of their decision to sack Voss so early in the season. Josh Fraser’s initial impact was subtle but significant. The make-up of players outside the competition makes the slow midfield look less leggy. Being structured to defend the ball going out of the contest and being ready to defend and tackle has already made them a team not entirely dependent on stoppages to score goals. They play with a system and a desire to put pressure and now they create turnovers.
They give the impression of a team and group of coaches who understand their mistakes and what needs to be done to correct them. They seem like a side that wants to shout that we were never this bad.
They not only beat Port Adelaide, who looked like they wouldn’t make it to the final, but they were another side one above them in the standings. Another side where Carlton said we should never be below you in the pecking order.
Normally when caretakers come on a mission they bring a simple instruction to the team in the final moments of the season to simplify the game, to understand that the pressure is off, so go out and play freely and enjoy yourself. The Fraser experience looks a little different from that. Admittedly, there are instructions to have fun and play adventurously, but there also seems to be more basic things he takes care of, which means the rest of the season is as much a training process as typical babysitting, and the players and coach have no responsibilities whatsoever.
Jagga Smith’s post-match comments were instructive. He wanted to be careful not to disrespect Voss, for whom the players clearly had and still have great affection, but he could not hide his excitement about the change in the team under Fraser. Winning does that. It changes all moods. Don’t Carlton people, aged 1-8 and desperate, feel better about the club than they did two weeks ago?
Two wins won’t change Fraser’s mind about wanting the senior job and shouldn’t change Carlton’s mind about who he wants to coach either.
It is academic and unwarranted to wonder whether Carlton will win the two games under Voss. The truth was, they knew they wouldn’t continue working with him the next year, so work began on the replacement. The first signs of the impact of initiating change are good.
The Bombers are the worst in the standings; no surprise
Given the relative standings of their seasons and tenure as coaches, it’s hard not to use Carlton as a reference point for Essendon.
Describing Essendon as the worst team in the tournament is a big statement. Not.
This is not an assessment based on losing to Richmond, who are still below them in the standings on a percentage basis, in a game where the Bombers lost four players to injury and had any realistic chance of winning the game with them. A statement based on them winning one match in 12 months.
When Carlton sacked Voss they did so in the loss of the lead by repeatedly commenting “We’re 1st and 8th” and it couldn’t continue like this. Essendon are currently in 1st and 9th place. They cling to the fact that the club knows the route and long-term strategy. And this is true.
Richmond came down from an already very high level, holding on to older players and mentoring their younger teammates while amassing top draft picks. Not at Essendon. They took the kids, but they didn’t have access to the best kids until this year. That will change in November, when they will have the first few picks in the draft.
They have older players, but they don’t have players with the leadership, sacrifice and on-field impact that Richmond has.
Friday night was instructive. Richmond have suffered horrific injuries across the group but still have an experienced core of Tim Taranto, Jayden Short, Nathan Broad, Jacob Hopper, Nick Vlastuin and Tom Lynch. There are no such leaders at Essendon.
Darcy Parish, often guilty of losing possession without leaving a mark, was outstanding with the way he handled the ball on Friday night. Zach Merrett continues to play at a high level while gritting his teeth on whether he wants to be there. There’s no Nic Martin around, Mason Redman is trying and Andy McGrath’s jaw is on wires now.
They had injuries last year as an explanation for their situation. The injuries were also announced on Friday, but they were all in-game collision injuries. The wider fitness issue was resolved in the off-season with the introduction of the highly respected Mathew Innes.
Voss’ sacking and Fraser’s immediate impact begs the question of whether a different coach could have achieved anything different at Essendon. This is doubtful.
But many managements twitch under pressure and the next games (West Coast away, Carlton and Melbourne) will invite more severe pressure if they continue to lose.
Brad Scott recently said that winning or losing games of this nature would not change anything in Essendon’s big picture, given the path they have agreed to rebuild the list at the end of 2023. This is understandable and fair.
But the longer and deeper Essendon’s losing streak becomes, the more despair and pessimism engulfs the club, and the further attendance declines despite the crowds turning out for the event/match on Friday night, the more vexing becomes for the Bombers the question of how long they can hold the line.
Emergency ward of the North (law)
In the most off-Broadway play you can get, it was overshadowed by a catfight for the top of the ladder and the Pendlebury extravaganza, and the fact that you were North Melbourne and you were playing Gold Coast at the Docklands on a winter Saturday provided North Melbourne absolute box office.
This game. This last quarter replay from LDU (Luke Davies-Uniacke), Cam Zurhaar and George Wardlaw deserved better than a footnote to the weekend.
Undoubtedly, it came out of Suns Darwin, baked or steamed and oiled. They became orange traffic cones with slightly less movement in the last quarter.
Regardless, North achieved the second-biggest come-from-behind win in club history. They did this by playing loose football that took advantage of the Suns’ inertia.
Clarkson scrapped the labels. Wardlaw had made only a modest impact on Matt Rowell, but had 13 touches and was involved in five points in the final quarter, tying the game in the lane with LDU. Zurhaar took the lead again and played like someone who promises to be good and begs not to be sent to the naughty corner again.
The momentum in the last quarter made us feel that victory was inevitable against the team that was standing still. So was Zurhaar supposed to try his luck after the siren?
Once Zurhaar was correctly paid his holding fee, Nick Larkey continued playing and took advantage to try and score the winning score. Then he lost his footing. It has been proven that there is no advantage, but this is rarely the test of the rule; What matters is not whether you get an advantage, but whether you take advantage of it. And he used this advantage.
There were still about 40 seconds left to score level, but so had the game been called to continue with the advantage, probably with the ball in the goal square and most likely a stoppage and vomiting, the North would still have scored something in those seconds and won. Yes, very hypothetical.
golden moment
There was almost a fatigue in Pendlebury when the game came on Saturday as it felt like he was being trolled and bored at every moment. However, he was saved from getting overly excited by the fans themselves. 90,000 people turned out for a match that ended in a draw, half that number in normal times. It was saved by applause in the 10th minute when play was stopped because there was reason to take a throw-in, but the players and referees intuitively thought it would be rude to restart while the applause was still ongoing, so the stop continued and the record was confirmed.
A day that was in danger of being overdone ended up being extraordinarily good.


