Would YOU be happy with a porcelain ring? As baby-faced royal Samuel Chatto proposes with handmade band, the other celeb engagement jewellery that failed to impress – including Megan Fox’s ‘painful’ thorned bespoke piece

A proposal marks the beginning of a lifelong commitment for couples, but for those obsessed with the finer details, this milestone moment is also about the ring.

From timeless solitaires to extravagant halos studded with diamonds, many brides-to-be dream of buying the perfect engagement ring.

But in the world of the rich and famous, where there’s never a shortage of luxury jewellery, it often pays to ditch tradition when popping the question and opt for something a little more unusual.

The last person to divide opinions was Princess Margaret’s grandson, 29-year-old Samuel Chatto, who proposed to his artist friend Eleanor Ekserdjian with a porcelain ring he had made.

While many praised the thoughtful, handcrafted movement, others questioned the usefulness of the band and some described it as ‘breakable’.

But the baby-faced ceramist isn’t the only famous face to surprise fans with her unconventional ring choice.

Read on to find out which celebrities prefer truly unexpected designs…

Samuel Chatto

Princess Margaret’s heartthrob grandson announced his engagement to 29-year-old Eleanor Ekserdjian yesterday with a unique porcelain ring he had crafted with his own hands.

The simple cream-coloured band has an elegant finish rather than a traditional gemstone.

But while many praised this emotional gesture and craftsmanship, others questioned the usefulness of the fragile material; critics called it ‘breakable’ and unsuitable for daily use.

One person wrote to X: ‘Are there no diamonds left in the safe? Princess Margaret would be spinning in her jar!’

Another said: ‘Porcelain? ‘He hits his hand on anything that could break’, while a third added: ‘Stunning ring, but I was afraid it would break.’

“I hope there is a secret ingredient that will make it unbreakable,” one concerned fan wrote. ‘I’m worried about it breaking. “I accidentally broke a lot of porcelain,” he said.

Rita Ora

Singer Rita Ora’s ring, which she received from filmmaker Taika Waititi, has a square-shaped Colombian emerald framed in diamond pavé

Rita Ora’s engagement ring from New Zealand filmmaker Taika Waititi, worth an estimated £416,000, features a stunning design featuring a square Colombian emerald in a diamond pavé-set frame and finished with a yellow gold band.

The vintage style of the ring won over many fans when the 35-year-old British singer and her 50-year-old husband got engaged in 2022, but others thought differently.

One person wrote: reddit subject: ‘Rita Ora’s ring cost a fortune but my first impression was that it looked like one of those toy rings that come in the 25 cent box.’

Emma Louise Connolly

Made In Chelsea star Oliver Proudlock proposed to Scottish model Emma Louise Connolly in 2018 to gift her an unusual octagon-shaped ring with black and green diamonds.

Scottish model Emma Louise Connolly, 34, received a striking octagon-shaped ring from her then-boyfriend Oliver Proudlock, 37, as they got engaged in 2018 and married two years later.

The bold, quirky ring was designed by the Made In Chelsea star and featured a diamond from her grandmother’s ring in the centre, surrounded by rows of black and white diamonds and green gemstones.

While some praised its unique and ‘stunning’ look, others thought the ring’s thick setting was a bit overwhelming.

on Instagram to post Uploaded by @vowjewellery, the makers of the ring, one person wrote: ‘Brutal’.

Another agreed and wrote: ‘This isn’t the best.’

Princess Marie of Denmark

Princess Marie’s signature ring features a central diamond surrounded by rubies and sapphires, a nod to her French heritage

Prince Joachim of Denmark proposed to Princess Marie in Türkiye in 2007 with a distinctive ring featuring a central diamond with rubies and sapphires and surrounded by a wide gold band.

To honor Marie’s French heritage, now 50, the £30,000 design features red, white and blue stones in a nod to the French flag.

While the colorful design commemorates the former businesswoman’s legacy, not everyone is convinced; some have suggested that the living ring belonged to the finger of a pirate rather than a member of the royal family.

In the Royal Forums threadone person said: ‘The contrast of blue, white and red on such a thick gold band looks as if it would suit Jack Sparrow’s finger better than the finger of a future royal princess of Denmark.’

Another criticized: ‘Three ‘busy’ colors in a ring and then adding gold as a fourth color is not good. ‘She lacks grace and that’s a shame.’

Megan Fox

The ring features a pear-shaped emerald and thorns designed to harm the player if they remove them.

In 2022, rapper Machine Gun Kelly, 36, proposed to Megan Fox, 40, with a bespoke $400,000 (£297,000) toi et moi ring (French for ‘you and me’) featuring pear-shaped emerald diamonds, each representing half of the couple.

According to singer-songwriter Kelly, who conceived the track, the stones rested on magnetic tapes covered in hidden spines; These tapes would hurt if the player tried to remove the ring.

Some admired the symbolism and devotion to love and marriage, but many described the design as more disturbing than romantic.

on Instagram to postone person wrote: ‘Anyone else see this as a huge red flag?’ Another commented: ‘Tell me it’s poisonous before I tell you it’s poisonous.’

A third added: ‘Yes “cute and romantic” except for when she wants to shower or put on lotion and can’t take it off unless she wants to hurt herself.’

After an on-and-off relationship, the couple sadly split following the birth of their daughter, Saga Blade, in March 2025.

Scarlet Johansson

Actress Scarlett Johansson’s engagement ring is an unusual, 11-carat diamond ring mounted on a dark, sculptural, curved ceramic band.

Scarlett Johansson’s engagement ring from Saturday Night Live star Colin Jost features a yellow-brown, elongated, 11-carat diamond mounted on a dark, sculptural, curved ceramic band designed by luxury jeweler Taffin.

Worth around $450,000 (£335,000), the 41-year-old actress’s modern dome-shaped design, which she bought in 2019, stood out among traditional engagement rings.

While some hailed the ring’s ‘cool’ center diamond, others admitted it wasn’t quite to their taste.

on reddit thread, one person wrote: ‘This is a beautiful stone but that band looks weird.’

Separately threadAnother described the ring as ‘disgusting’, while a third added: ‘I hate the layout of this ring so much.’

Ariana Grande

Dalton Gomez proposed to Ariana Grande in 2014 with a ring featuring a large oval-cut diamond and pearl believed to have been taken from his grandfather’s tie clip.

The ring that Ariana Grande received from her ex-husband Dalton Gomez asymmetrically combines a large oval-cut diamond and an offset pearl.

Sharing an image of the $750,000 (£559,000) ring on X (formerly Twitter) in 2014, the 7 Rings singer wrote: ‘Nonna had a ring made for me with the pearl from my grandfather’s tie pin. He says in his dream you told him it would protect me.’

Ariana’s grandmother, Marjorie (Nonna), had a special ring made for her using the pearl she took from her late grandfather’s tie clip. The pearl in the engagement ring is believed to be the same family heirloom, according to British Vogue.

The unusual pairing has been widely praised for its sentimental meaning, but others have questioned its practicality, noting that pearls are one of the softest gemstones and can easily be scratched or damaged by daily use.

Fine jewelry by brand AngaraPearls are only a 2.5 on the Mohs scale (which measures a material’s scratch resistance, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the hardest), making them risky for everyday use.

One person wrote on Reddit: to post: ‘This is one of the WORST materials to use for everyday use because they are so delicate. I’m sure he knows that too.”

Another agreed, commenting: ‘Pearls aren’t ideal for an engagement ring and since pearls are sentimental I can only assume she’ll wear them on special occasions.’

Paris Hilton

Chris Zylka proposed to Paris Hilton, 45, with a 20-carat pear-shaped diamond ring in 2018

In 2018, American actor and model Chris Zylka proposed to Paris Hilton, 45, with a breathtaking 20-carat pear-shaped diamond ring worth an estimated $2 million (£1.4 million).

The huge sparkler placed on a platinum band covered with diamonds became almost as famous as the proposal itself.

It later made headlines after the heiress temporarily lost it at a Miami nightclub, leading many to joke that such an extravagant ring would always be impractical.

At the time, one person reacted sarcastically to Paris’s X. to post: ‘Example of the most unfortunate problem of the rich: The diamond in my engagement ring is so heavy that I lost it!’

Another joked: ‘I knew you’d lose that thing at least once.’

katy perry

On Valentine’s Day 2019, Orlando Bloom proposed to pop singer Katy Perry with a ring shaped like a blooming flower

Pirates of the Caribbean star Orlando Bloom, 49, proposed to pop singer Katy Perry, 41, with a unique cluster set ring in the shape of a blooming flower on Valentine’s Day 2019.

The striking ring, said to be worth around £4 million, featured a large oval pink gemstone, believed to be a ruby ​​or vibrant pink diamond, surrounded by eight white diamonds.

Fans and commenters online heavily criticized the ring, with many tagging it. the floral aesthetic is childish and ‘ugly’.

One person wrote on Reddit: thread: ‘Oh my god Katy Perry’s ring is SO ugly.’

Another said: ‘I hate Katy! Looks like a 5 year old picked it out.’

A third added: ‘Orlando should have gone with a simple and beautiful ring instead of a statement piece. A flower ring does not match every outfit. ‘Hush.’

The couple never made it to the altar, splitting in 2025 after almost a decade together.