‘How will this get me back to work quicker?’ Readers fear plans to ‘scrap’ sick notes

A.As the government prepares to trial major changes to the sickness reporting system in some parts of England, many people Independent Readers have raised concerns about plans to see some patients referred by their GP to work and health coaches rather than sick leave.

Under pilot programmes, GPs in some areas will stop providing appropriate notes altogether, instead referring patients to support services staffed by a mix of clinical and non-clinical staff who will create personalized “return to work” plans. The government says the reforms are designed to move away from the “tick box” system and help more people stay committed to work while they recover.

But many readers said the quotes misunderstand how proper notes are used in real life.

A recurring theme throughout the comments was that fitness notes often help people stay at work during periods of serious illness rather than taking time off from work.

Readers have shared their experiences using proper notes while recovering from heart conditions, cancer treatment, mental health issues, and chronic illnesses; Many people said employers rely on them to make adjustments or approve phased returns.

Some have warned that removing doctors from the process could put vulnerable people under pressure to return to work too early; Others have questioned whether non-clinical staff can safely assess someone’s health needs without proper medical supervision.

Here’s what you need to say:

Fit notes helped me keep my job

I needed a decent grade that would help me keep my job. A recent heart condition means I am unable to carry out more strenuous tasks and I often fall ill. My employer was very proactive, but quite reasonably requested a suitable grade. I’m not sure how to change this. If it’s being published in large numbers, that’s a GP issue, right?

ButchersPen

GPs should also be challenged

This completely removes the responsibilities of GPs! People this, people that. How about you talk a little to the doctors who give out sick reports as if they were smart? They are medical professionals; They should not be fooled, but they are never discussed as part of the problem. You cannot get a sick or healthy report without a general practitioner! Take it to them, challenge them and at the same time if GPs believe they are giving the correct diagnosis, treatment and grade then they need to challenge the government and third parties such as support services and say “I’m the medical expert here, stand back!” They should say.

leaf spot

Sick notes prevented homelessness

Without my latest sickness certificates from the GP, I would not have been able to access Universal Credit and my self-employment income protection insurance; Without this insurance, I would have been homeless recovering from workplace injuries. This was not thought through properly.

ilearthstoner

Not an oppressive, sensible pilot

For all the noise, this memo pilot is not the dawn of a Dickensian edition; This is what happens when two real adult elders are left alone in government long enough to tidy up a corner of the room. One of them has the rare distinction of being both competent and unflappable, while the other survived being stabbed by a voter a few years ago and is still returning to work – which, in the current climate, is considered a borderline-mythical quality of resilience.

Between them, they accomplished something almost suspiciously sensible: a small-scale test to see if the system could be returned to sanity without penalizing people who were actually sick. Real cases may still have paper trails; This is Britain, after all, where bureaucracy is the closest thing we have to a national religion.

But because we live in a fast-fashion political culture, every pilot project is treated like a constitutional crisis. In reality it’s just two adults saying “Let’s try this properly, measure it and adjust it if necessary”, which is so contrary to the usual Westminster theatrics that it feels almost revolutionary.

On the contrary, the country needs to relax: for once, the state machinery is run by people who don’t panic, don’t postulate, and don’t feel the need to check with a focus group before deciding whether the sky is blue or not.

DancingTheKneeJerkCanCan

It’s either suitable for the job or it’s not.

You’re either eligible or you’re not. It appears that independent, non-clinical experts are being used to determine that this is a retrograde step.

Of course, work should not be toxic and employers should be responsible for managing their business in collaboration with those running it, ensuring people are fit for work and are not encouraged to return too early. I speak as a former employer at businesses large and small that I have owned.

Our health secretary should focus on why people get or continue to get sick, what speeds recovery, and what factors contribute to illness in our work environment (e.g. poor health and safety practices, high stress levels, parental pressures and overwork, stress from targets and punishments in schools, and more).

Andrew

How will this help me get back to work faster?

I’m currently on a note on the form saying I’m not available for work.

I had emergency surgery last weekend. Until I am well enough to return to my laboratory work safely, I must obtain a sick note in order to receive statutory sick pay after seven days. I would appreciate it if some arrangements could be made so that I could return to work sooner, but due to the nature of my job this is not possible.

I wonder how the government thinks people will magically heal after surgery or injuries? Or how will taking me out of the house and going to a “business counselor” when I need to rest help me get back to work quicker?

Actually

The pain made it impossible to go back

Two years ago I had a severe sciatica attack. There’s no way I can work as a bus driver. I tried going back a few times but the pain was too intense. However, I returned after a break of almost four months. We still suffer from its effects today. How do they think they can get me back sooner – God help those in a similar situation…

Polheg

Forcing patients to return to work

So they will go after patients and force them to work, using non-clinical staff to deprive them of financial support, so in a world of abundance we basically have to work ourselves to death. People like me, who have just recovered from two cancer surgeries, will have to work regardless of fatigue and illness, rather than waiting for support. Every day, people will have to measure this against non-clinical study coaches who earn points by pushing patients to study. How about the government reverse pay for top executives and bankers and stop wars to save money?

goodbyedinosaur

Healthcare decisions belong to the NHS

If possible, returning to being fit and healthy enough to work 9-5 Monday to Friday, for example, is the BEST NHS support.

The DWP knows nothing about a person’s health and is legally responsible for a person’s injury, illness etc. He/she must NOT know anything about personal details – even acute or chronic – regarding

Medicine is the NHS and only the NHS.

CAMPAIGNS4UKMs1983

Cancer patients still face more hurdles

Let’s say you are diagnosed with cancer and need urgent treatment. A proper note and discussions with your employer will ensure you have the time needed for treatment and recovery.

But Starmer’s Labor thinks these people have it easy. So not only do you have to negotiate with your employer, you also have to negotiate with a person without a medical history who is worth the job. Of course, not waiting for these services for a year would be breaking tradition.

Do they hope that people will die without receiving even a penny of sick pay?

TalkingSense

Five years from note to treatment

The problem is not the sick note. The problem is trying to find a path to treatment.

I discovered this in 2010. After many workarounds, I had to have a complete knee replacement because I couldn’t function at work. It took five years from receiving the first medical report to performing the surgery.

NineyTheObserver

Some of the comments in this article have been edited for brevity and clarity.

I want to share your opinions? To log in or register simply click ‘sign in’ or ‘sign up’ in the top right corner. Once you sign up, you can comment on the day’s top stories to showcase your views.

Want your voice to stand out? Independent Bonus Subscribers have priority in featured comments. Subscriber Here.

Be sure to follow our community guidelines, which you can find at. Here. For a complete guide on how to comment, Click here.