Justice Kennedy reflects on his time deciding the Constitution’s promise of liberty and equality

WASHINGTON— Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, the Supreme Court’s most influential member before his retirement, watched quietly for eight years as a new conservative majority took over.
He was upset with partisan gerrymandering, but a year after he resigned, a 5-4 decision closed federal courts to challenges to state voting maps that allowed a party to rig elections in its favor.
Although he believed abortion was a moral wrong, in 1992 he cast a landmark vote in Roe vs. He supported Wade and the principle that a woman, not the government, has the right to decide whether to terminate an early pregnancy.
Four years ago, that decision was overturned by a vote of 5 to 4.
While Kennedy declined to comment on the current court or President Trump, he wrote a memoir that tells his life story and explains the reasoning behind the key decisions of his era.
It has become common for judges to write books, but they avoid writing about the court’s work. Kennedy’s book, “Life, Law and Freedom”, like justice, is the exception to this rule.
Kennedy, an Irish Catholic from Sacramento and a Republican from Reagan, had a generally conservative voting history on the high court for more than 30 years. But he had a different view on freedom and justice.
“The nature of injustice is that we cannot always see it in our own time.” wrote in 2015.
Kennedy rejected the “rigid” view that the Constitution’s promises of equal protection of liberty and law, as well as protection against cruel and unusual punishment, were limited to their “original” meaning in the Bill of Rights of 1791 or the 14th Amendment of 1868.
After all, slavery and segregation were legal for most of American history, and women were not protected from discrimination by the promise of “equal protection” in the 14th Amendment.
Kennedy remained open to new rights and freedoms. The goal, he wrote, is “a decent society where the Constitution and the rule of law treat everyone with dignity and equality.”
He was the judge who made a difference in many areas of law; None of these were as important as LGBTQ+ rights.
He wrote the court’s four major decisions rejecting discrimination based on sexual orientation. In 2015, he spoke on behalf of a 5-4 majority in support of same-sex marriage nationwide.
“No union is deeper than marriage, for marriage embodies the highest ideals of love, fidelity, commitment, sacrifice and family,” he wrote. “Many same-sex couples provide loving and caring homes for their children, whether biological or adopted. And hundreds of thousands of children are currently being raised by such couples.”
Obergefell vs. “They want equal dignity before the law. The Constitution gives them that right,” he concluded in the Hodges case.
He also believed that young people who committed crimes were not as guilty as adults. Wrote a court opinion in 2005 ending executions of murderers Those who were under the age of 18 when the crime was committed.
Five years later, he wrote the court’s opinion that it was cruel and unusual punishment for judges to sentence a teenager to life in prison with no chance of parole for a crime that did not involve murder. at tA Florida teenager was sentenced to life in prison in the case before the court For armed robbery and burglary before his 18th birthday.
Kennedy celebrated his 90th birthday on Thursday and said his favorite topic of conversation was not his nine judges but his nine grandchildren. He is currently in court for several days and says he is concerned about the attitude in Washington and across the country.
“This is too partisan and confrontational,” he told The Times in a recent interview. “I am concerned that separatism will be reflected in the court.”
He said democracy requires “reasoned and respectful debate,” not personal attacks and name-calling.
University of Washington law professor Daniel Epps, a former Kennedy clerk, said Kennedy may be the last justice of his kind.
“I don’t think we’ll ever see another judge who is so ideologically unpredictable and votes against the party to which he was appointed in some of the biggest cases in our lifetimes,” he said. Kennedy emerged from “a less polarized appointment process where there were conservative Democrats and liberal Republicans and there were filibusters in the Senate, and all of that made it possible for moderates to be appointed.”
Although Kennedy sometimes described himself as a small-town lawyer from Sacramento, he knew two California governors, both Republicans, who reshaped the Supreme Court.
Kennedy’s father was a friend of Governor Earl Warren, and young Tony played with Warren’s children. He also worked as a junior page at the State Capitol during Warren’s time as governor.
In 1954, Warren, the new chief justice, was a senior in high school when she spoke on behalf of a unanimous court to desegregate the Brown v. Board of Education case.
He and his father agreed that the decision was long overdue. It also provided an early lesson in how justices could uphold the basic principles of the Constitution despite intense opposition from much of the country.
He later said he took a second lesson. Brown’s decision was “a historic step forward” but “only a beginning” in the fight against entrenched racial injustice.
In writing about the same-sex marriage case, Kennedy cited Loving vs. Loving, which struck down interracial marriage bans in 16 states in 1967. He cited Warren’s opinion in the Virginia case.
As a young lawyer, Kennedy worked on special projects for Governor Ronald Reagan and greatly admired him. He was just 38 years old when he was appointed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit by order of Reagan.
A decade later, as president, Reagan appointed Justices Sandra Day O’Connor and Antonin Scalia to the Supreme Court and named William Rehnquist as chief justice. However, his third nominee, Judge Robert Bork, was rejected by the Senate on the grounds that he was too conservative.
Reagan invited Kennedy to the White House and offered him his candidacy. Kennedy recalled telling Reagan that he and his wife, Mary, were happy in Sacramento, where all their friends and family lived. “We don’t know anyone in Washington,” he said.
President Reagan points to the family of Justice Anthony M. Kennedy after nominating Kennedy to the Supreme Court in 1987.
(Dennis Cook / Associated Press)
In his best imitation of Reagan’s voice, he relayed the president’s response: “You know me. And you know Nancy, too.”
Kennedy accepted the nomination and was confirmed by a vote of 97-0 in February 1988; He became the last judge to receive unanimous confirmation from the Senate.
His three decades in the field were shaped in part by his relationship with Scalia.
Kennedy and his wife bought a house in the northern Virginia neighborhood where Scalia lived. During their first years in the field, they seemed like friends and allies.
They broadly supported freedom of expression. To the surprise of many, they voted in 1989 to rule that the 1st Amendment protected the right to burn the American flag in protest.
A year later, Kennedy and Scalia strongly dissented when the court ruled that the Michigan Chamber of Commerce and its corporate backers could be barred from touting their support for state candidates.
The decision triggered a decades-long dispute that culminated in the Citizens United decision in 2010. Kennedy spoke on behalf of a 5-4 conservative majority to rule that corporations, unions and other groups were free to independently spend money to oppose or support candidates.
But when the court was closely divided on major cases, Kennedy was likely in the majority, with Scalia writing scathing and increasingly personal dissent.
“I would hide my head in a bag,” Scalia wrote in his dissent in the same-sex marriage case, rather than subscribe to an opinion “that stands out for a style that is as ostentatious as it is selfish in its content.”
Kennedy stalled with a different move. Scalia said the justices do not represent the entire country. For example, he wrote in court that “there are no real Westerners (California doesn’t count).”
Since Scalia’s death, his influence has grown, especially among a younger generation of conservatives.
Two of Trump’s appointees — Justices Neil M. Gorsuch and Brett M. Kavanaugh — were clerks for Kennedy in 1993, but they are much more likely to quote Scalia and his views on interpretation of the law or the Constitution. Judge Amy Coney Barrett, Trump’s third appointee, clerked for Scalia.
While Kennedy did not respond to Scalia’s harsh dissent, they spent their final year together on the court.
One day in early February 2016, Scalia stopped by Kennedy’s office to talk.
“Nino said he deeply regretted the Obergefell opponent’s tone and personal references. He apologized for acting excessively,” Kennedy wrote. “Neither of us are very good at hugging, but we did, and we were both smiling.”
When he returned from a hunting trip to Texas, he and his wives decided to get together for dinner.
A week later, Scalia’s wife, Maureen, called to tell him he had died.
“Nino and I spent 28 years together in the field,” Kennedy wrote. “Sometimes we agreed, sometimes we didn’t, but I respected him and I missed him terribly.”



